Unemployment and job insecurity are pressing social issues that justify government intervention through active labour market policies (ALMPs). Among these, self-employment promotion has gained traction in Europe due to its dual effect on unemployment reduction: directly by removing individuals from unemployment and indirectly by creating additional jobs. However, the contribution of these policies remains under-researched, particularly regarding their effects on self-employed earnings. This study evaluates the association of eight ALMPs on the earnings of self-employed workers in Andalusia, Spain—a region with the country’s highest unemployment rate (16.1% in Q1 2025). Using an ad hoc questionnaire distributed to over 1200 self-employed individuals, the analysis measures the difference between current earnings and prior salaries as employees. The study employs a partial proportional odds model (PPOM) and highlights that the measures related to free courses and discounts for hiring workers may lead to better earnings for beneficiaries of these policies. The findings aim to guide more effective use of public resources, ensuring future entrepreneurial initiatives foster sustainable self-employment and job creation.
Research on the informal economy has traditionally emphasized its measurement and macroeconomic effects, focusing on structural and institutional determinants. Individual psychological factors that may help explain social tolerance toward informal practices have received far less attention. This exploratory study addresses this gap by examining how Big Five personality traits and dimensions of competitiveness are associated with two components of tolerance: the acceptance of informal behaviors, and justificatory beliefs. To this end, an ad hoc questionnaire was developed, and a cross-sectional design was implemented using a stratified sample of 339 students enrolled in Business Administration programs at a Spanish university. Multivariable models estimated these associations while adjusting for gender. The results indicate that conscientiousness and extraversion are negatively associated with both acceptance and justificatory beliefs, whereas competitive affectivity exhibits a positive and consistent association with both dimensions. Within the study sample, tolerance scores were higher among male respondents. These findings raise a hypothesis for future research: awareness campaigns may achieve greater precision when they account for psychological heterogeneity. This implication should be tested in broader and more diverse populations. Drawing on this exploratory evidence, we propose a preliminary analytical model that articulates the relationships between dispositional traits and competitiveness dimensions in relation to the two components of tolerance, providing a basis for future research. From a theoretical perspective, the proposed model offers a structured basis for longitudinal testing and future experimental designs aimed at deepening the understanding of the microfoundational mechanisms underlying the informal economy.
Active labor market policies (ALMPs) targeting self-employment have become a well-established and relevant instrument within employment promotion strategies across many European countries. However, despite their strategic and economic importance, there is limited evidence on their potential performance prior to implementation. This paper aims to address this gap by conducting an ex-ante cost–benefit simulation of different types of ALMPs designed to promote self-employment in Spain. The methodology is based on estimating public costs per beneficiary and quantifiable potential benefits, including avoided welfare payments, additional tax revenues, and the generation of economic activity. These benefits are adjusted using two key parameters: additionality (the proportion of the effect genuinely attributable to the policy) and persistence (the duration of the impact over time). In addition, three sensitivity scenarios (conservative, baseline, and favorable) are developed. The results suggest that financing and access to credit policies exhibit the most robust returns, while direct subsidies, general tax incentives, and emergency policies are more sensitive to intervention design features. Consequently, the effectiveness of ALMPs targeting self-employment depends fundamentally on their ability to align with the specific frictions faced by potential entrepreneurs and on the persistence of their effects.