Legacy mining facilities pose significant risks to aquatic resources. From March 30th to April 9th, 2021, 814 million liters of phosphate mining wastewater and marine dredge water from the Piney Point facility were released into lower Tampa Bay (Florida, USA). This resulted in an estimated addition of 186 metric tons of total nitrogen, exceeding typical annual external nitrogen load estimates to lower Tampa Bay in a matter of days. An initial phytoplankton bloom (non-harmful diatoms) was first observed in April. Filamentous cyanobacteria blooms (Dapis spp.) peaked in June, followed by a bloom of the red tide organism Karenia brevis. Reported fish kills tracked K. brevis concentrations, prompting cleanup of over 1600 metric tons of dead fish. Seagrasses had minimal changes over the study period. By comparing these results to baseline environmental monitoring data, we demonstrate adverse water quality changes in response to abnormally high and rapidly delivered nitrogen loads.
Nitrogen pollution is a complex 21st century environmental challenge with profound negative effects on coastal communities. Engineering solutions alone are insufficient for addressing this. Here we describe an innovative approach to making nitrogen pollution, its causes, and solutions understandable to those most affected by it through an interactive web-based platform, videos, storytelling, art exhibits, and documentary films. A critical aspect of the project structure was identifying and collaborating with local community leaders from the outset. Their experiences as environmental advocates and their community connections fundamentally shaped the direction of the project, benefitting both advocates (referred to as ‘Alliance members’), their organizations, ‘underestimated communities,’ and the research team. Codesigning the research project with community leaders ensured the research aligned with community priorities, thereby enhancing the applicability of the research. Working across geographies, disciplines, backgrounds, and experiences can be challenging. The team took numerous steps, including multiple site visits to each location, workshops on systems thinking for team members, community arts and film screening events, and regular virtual meetings, to address these challenges. The success of the project and the codesign approach underscore the importance of looking to expand beyond traditional engineering approaches to encompass humanistic approaches such as storytelling and visual media to connect with ongoing community efforts.
Changing climatic conditions that can alter physical characteristics of surface waters may limit the effectiveness of conventional approaches to nutrient management. This study evaluated the competing effects of nutrient loads and changing salinity on chlorophyll-a dynamics in Tampa Bay (Florida, USA). This estuary has demonstrated long-term recovery of water quality primarily through wastewater infrastructure improvements, whereas a gradual freshening of the bay over the last few decades may compromise future management efforts to protect water quality. The relative effects of loading and salinity over a forty-year time period were evaluated using normalized predictions from Generalized Additive Models (GAMs). All bay segments showed a gradually increasing influence of reduced salinity on chlorophyll-a. Old Tampa Bay in the northwest also showed an increasing influence of nutrient loading. Simulation scenarios using the GAMs assessed the relative likelihood of exceeding regulatory chlorophyll-a standards under future salinity conditions. All bay segments showed an increased likelihood of exceeding regulatory standards, particularly in Old Tampa Bay where likelihood increased by ~ 16% over a fifty-year simulation. The results suggested that current nutrient loads should be substantially reduced below the federally-recognized Total Maximum Daily Load to maintain likelihood of meeting regulatory chlorophyll-a standards in the future that is similar to present. By understanding the effects of largely unmanageable characteristics of the bay, water quality managers can reassess efforts on limiting factors they can control relative to those they cannot.