New battery materials with improved transport are needed. Typical measurements yield widely varying voltage-dependent diffusivities and reporting practices are diverse. Some materials (e.g. first-order phase change) have most redox occur at a specific voltage and may be sufficiently represented by singular transport metrics. Many rapid intercalation materials, however, exhibit second-order phase transitions with redox over a broad voltage range. How should such cases be compared? The use of capacity-weighted average values is suggested where voltage-dependent metrics are consolidated into representative descriptors as figures-of-merit. Examples are elaborated where differential capacity (dQ/dV) is used to derive a weighting function to calculate a diffusivity figure-of-merit (DQav). Furthermore, it is shown that galvanostatic techniques can provide transport values with even capacity-weighting such that their mean value (DTav) is capacity-weighted. Though equivalent conceptually, the latter approach avoids derivative noise and subjective smoothing. Computational diffusion calculations can similarly include capacity-weighted figures-of-merit. Lastly, diffusivity uncertainty is last addressed which is dominated by surface area error due to the second-power dependence. Best-practices can reduce the diffusivity error from ~40% to ~2% using appropriate BET sorbents or SAXS thickness measurements. These perspectives improve the comparison of battery materials with a diffusivity figure-of-merit that supports performance-ranking with attention to uncertainty.
The controlled preparation of porous nanomaterials from block polymer templates is important for diverse applications from energy devices to optical coatings and sorbents. The architectural dimensions determine the overall performance for many of these applications, however the independent control of these dimensions has remained limited to a narrow range of solvent conditions for kinetically trapped (“persistent”) micelle templates. Polymers with a photo-reactive chemistry are shown to enable cross-linked micelle templates that universally remain persistent under diverse solvent conditions. Specifically, poly(poly(ethylene glycol methacrylate))-b-poly(butyl methacrylate-co-coumarin methacrylate) (OBC) was prepared by RAFT polymerization and the resulting micelles were crosslinked with UV light (X-OBC). TEM images revealed that crosslinking in MeOH-only led to a mixture of micelles and unimers whereas crosslinking in MeOH–H2O led to pure micelles. Absorbance measurements indicated 50% coumarin dimerization (crosslinking) occurred after 180 min of UV exposure. The near universal solvent compatibility of X-OBC persistent micelles is demonstrated with DLS measurements in toluene, DCM, DMF, THF, EtOH, and MeOH, whereas OBC is shown to release unimers in DCM, DMF, THF, and toluene, or precipitate from EtOH due to a morphology change. Spectroscopic testing of micelle crosslinking occurred at each templating step. Micelle entrapment was also validated with SAXS and SEM measurements after nanomaterial templating where X-OBC enabled sample series with constant pore size whereas OBC did not. Furthermore, the results uniquely show X-OBC micelle persistence when processed from non-selective solvents. These results highlight how molecular engineering and tailored processing can enable the generalized synthesis of controlled porous nanomaterials.