17 September 2022 in Annals of Operations Research
14 June 2022 in Computers & Industrial Engineering
8 March 2023 in Journal of the Operational Research Society
In group decision making (GDM), there may exist some problems that need to assign alternatives to some predefined ordered categories, which are called ordinal classification-based GDM problems. To obtain classification results that can be accepted by most decision makers (DMs), it is necessary to implement a consensus reaching process for ordinal classification-based GDM problems. In this paper, we study consensus reaching models for a new type of ordinal classification-based GDM problem, in which DMs do not provide criteria weights and category cardinalities but provide indirect and imprecise heterogeneous preference information. To do so, a consistency verification method is first proposed to check whether each DM’s preference information is consistent and then a minimum adjustment optimization model is developed to modify DMs’ inconsistent preference information. Afterwards, we establish some optimization models to obtain each DM’s possible categories for alternatives. Followed by this, we define the consensus levels of DMs and devise some optimization models to assist DMs in adjusting alternatives’ classification results and DMs’ preference information at the same time. Furthermore, a maximum support degree-based method is provided to determine the consensual classification result for alternatives. Finally, a numerical application and some sensitivity analysis are provided to justify the proposed models.
9 March 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems
In multicriteria group decision-making (MCGDM) problems, there exist the situations that alternatives need to be assigned to several predefined ordered categories rather than be ranked from the most preferred to the least preferred, which is called multicriteria group sorting problems. To address multicriteria group sorting problems, it is necessary to implement a consensus reaching process to fully consider the opinion of each decision maker and reduce the conflict among them. To do so, this article proposes a consensus reaching model for multicriteria group sorting problems based on the threshold-based value-driven sorting method from the perspective of minimum adjustment. Specifically, we first define the consensus measure to calculate the agreement degree among decision makers by considering the ordinal information and cardinal information at the same time. On this basis, we construct a minimum adjustment optimization model in terms of the threshold-based value-driven sorting method to assist decision makers in modifying their decision matrices and further promote consensus. Followed by this, an optimization model that aims to minimize the distance between all decision makers and the group with respect to alternatives’ comprehensive values and sorting results is developed to determine the group sorting result for alternatives. Moreover, a numerical application of urban park management, some sensitivity analysis, and simulation experiments are provided to justify the proposed method. Experimental results reveal that the proposed method is effective in promoting consensus.
5 December 2024 in European Journal of Operational Research
17 October 2024 in IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems
In the field of linguistic decision making, it is widely acknowledged that different individuals may have different understandings of the same linguistic information. Consequently, the modeling of personalized individual semantics (PISs) has emerged as a prominent research avenue within the domain of linguistic decision making. In this article, we study multicriteria decision making problems with incomplete linguistic preference relations (ILPRs), particularly in scenarios where the marginal utility function of each criterion remain elusive. We develop a new approach for modeling PISs of decision makers from the preference disaggregation perspective. The proposed method initiates by representing the marginal utility of each alternative regarding to every criterion, employing piecewise linear functions. It then customizes linguistic preference values within an ILPR by translating them into numerical preference intensities. Subsequently, this article formulates optimization models to check and rectify the inconsistencies between the multicriteria assessment information and the known elements in the ILPR. Furthermore, an optimization model is devised with the objective of minimizing the inconsistency index of the complete linguistic preference relation, thereby enabling the estimation of missing elements of the ILPR and the ranking of alternatives. Consequently, this method also facilitates the derivation of marginal utility functions and PISs for the decision maker. The proposed method is illustrated using a practical scenario involving a car purchase problem, substantiated by a series of simulation experiments and comparative analysis, ultimately providing validation for the proposed approach.