Rachel Ogilvie

Rachel Ogilvie

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Rachel Ogilvie

Department of Community Health & Epidemiology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
14 January 2019 in Diagnostic and Prognostic Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JHJill A. Hayden
Jill A. Hayden
RORachel Ogilvie
Rachel Ogilvie
SSSamuel Alan Stewart
Samuel Alan Stewart
SFSimon French
Simon French
SCSamuel Campbell
Samuel Campbell
ISIan Stiell
Ian Stiell
Low back pain is one of the most common and disabling health problems in Canada and internationally. In most cases, low back pain is a benign, self-limiting condition that can be managed with little diagnostic investigation or treatment. Yet contrary to clinical practice guideline recommendations, diagnostic imaging (here meaning X-ray, MRI, CT) is commonly used in the assessment of low back pain. Diagnostic imaging is of limited value in most cases, exposing patients to unnecessary radiation and leading to increased health services use and worse patient health outcomes. The Choosing Wisely campaign has highlighted the need to reduce diagnostic imaging for low back pain; however, no clinical decision rules are available. This project will develop a clinical decision support tool for appropriate use of diagnostic imaging for patients with low back pain in the emergency department. We will conduct a prospective cohort study at five Canadian emergency departments. The study will follow recommendations for prediction model development and testing. The study population will be 4000 patients presenting to the emergency department with low back pain. We will assess potential clinical indications of emergent-cause (i.e., “red flag” items), including clinical characteristics and past history. Our outcome, emergent-cause for low back pain such as fracture, cancer, infection, or cauda equina syndrome, will be assessed at discharge and at 1-, 3-, and 12-month follow-up periods using information from self-report and health administrative data. We will construct and assess the performance of a multivariable prediction model that has strong measurement properties, presented as a clinical decision support tool acceptable to knowledge users. Practice guidelines describe “red flags” for which diagnostic imaging is likely appropriate. However, recommendations across guidelines are discordant, and few studies have evaluated these criteria to determine which characteristics best predict emergent etiology that warrant diagnostic imaging. A clinical decision support tool, that recommends diagnostic imaging where appropriate, has the potential to improve clinical care and patient outcomes and reduce costs associated with managing low back pain patients.

1 June 2021 in Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JHJ.A. Hayden
J.A. Hayden
JEJ. Ellis
J. Ellis
ROR. Ogilvie
R. Ogilvie
LBL. Boulos
L. Boulos
SSS. Stanojevic
S. Stanojevic

7 January 2021 in Journal of the Medical Library Association
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LBLeah Boulos
Leah Boulos
RORachel Ogilvie
Rachel Ogilvie
JHJill A. Hayden
Jill A. Hayden
Objective: This study retroactively investigated the search methods used in the 2019 Hayden et al. study, one of the first systematic reviews of prognostic factors that was published in the Cochrane Library. The review was designed to address recognized weaknesses in reviews of prognosis by using multiple supplementary search methods in addition to traditional electronic database searching.Methods: The authors used four approaches to comprehensively assess aspects of systematic review literature searching for prognostic factor studies: (1) comparison of search recall of broad versus focused electronic search strategies, (2) linking of search methods of origin for eligible studies, (3) analysis of impact of supplementary search methods on meta-analysis conclusions, and (4) analysis of prognosis filter performance.Results: The review’s focused electronic search strategy resulted in a 91% reduction in recall, compared to a broader version. Had the team relied on the focused search strategy without using supplementary search methods, they would have missed 23 of 58 eligible studies that were indexed in MEDLINE; additionally, the number of included studies in 2 of the review’s primary outcome meta-analyses would have changed. Using a broader strategy without supplementary searches would still have missed 5 studies. The prognosis filter used in the review demonstrated the highest sensitivity of any of the filters tested.Conclusions: Our study results support recommendations for supplementary search methods made by prominent systematic review methodologists. Leaving out any supplemental search methods would have resulted in missed studies, and these omissions would not have been prevented by using a broader search strategy or any of the other prognosis filters tested.

16 October 2024 in Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SSSamuel Silva
Samuel Silva
SSSareen Singh
Sareen Singh
SKShazia Kashif
Shazia Kashif
RORachel Ogilvie
Rachel Ogilvie
RPRafael Z. Pinto
Rafael Z. Pinto
JHJill A. Hayden
Jill A. Hayden
The primary objectives were to describe characteristics of trial registration in the chronic low back pain (CLBP) field and assess the association of trial registration status (registered vs. unregistered, prospectively registered vs. retrospectively registered) with risk of bias, sufficient sample size, quality of reporting, and treatment effect estimates. Secondary objectives were to describe trial registration consistency with the final report and assess its association with risk of bias, sufficient sample size, and treatment effect estimates. A cross-sectional meta-epidemiological study of trials included in a large Cochrane review on exercise treatments for CLBP. We extracted relevant trial and registration information and assessed trials' risk of bias using the Cochrane RoB 1 tool. We performed descriptive analyses, logistic regressions, and subgroup meta-analyses. We included 361 trials, of which 23.3% were prospectively registered. Registered trials had lower risk of bias (OR 0.6; 95%CI 0.5, 0.7) and higher reporting quality (OR 1.6; 95%CI 1.4, 1.8) than unregistered trials. Prospectively registered trials were more likely to have low risk of reporting bias (OR 2.7; 95%CI 1.2, 6.5) and higher quality of reporting (OR 1.3; 95%CI 1.1, 1.6) than retrospectively registered trials. Trial registration status was not associated with effect estimates. Among prospectively registered trials, 64.3% clearly defined primary outcome(s) in their registration, 58.3% had consistent sample sizes, and 22.6% had no evidence of selective outcome reporting. Trials that clearly defined primary outcome(s) were more likely to report larger effect estimates for pain intensity (MD -15.8; 95%CI -22.7, -8.9 versus -6.0; 95%CI -10.6, -1.5; Q=6.7, p=0.01), although the difference was small, the 95%CIs overlapped, and no difference was found for functional limitations. A small proportion of trials in the CLBP field were registered prospectively and many presented registration inconsistencies. Registered trials tend to have lower risk of bias and higher quality of reporting. Policies are needed to improve prospective registration and registration consistency in the field.

22 August 2023 in Physical Therapy
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MGMitchell T Gibbs
Mitchell T Gibbs
JHJill A Hayden
Jill A Hayden
ACAidan G Cashin
Aidan G Cashin
BSBrishna Shah
Brishna Shah
YGYannick L Gilanyi
Yannick L Gilanyi
MJMatthew Jones
Matthew Jones
Objective: This study aimed to estimate the proportion of exercise interventions tested in clinical trials of people with chronic low back pain (CLBP) that meet the World Health Organization’s (WHO) physical activity guidelines. Methods: A secondary analysis of the 2021 Cochrane review of exercise therapy for CLBP was performed. Data from each study were extracted by 1 reviewer and were checked by a second reviewer. Data extracted related to the frequency, duration and intensity of each exercise intervention, and the proportion of exercise interventions that met the WHO’s physical activity guidelines (aerobic, muscle strengthening, or both) were determined. Results: The 249 included trials comprised 426 exercise interventions. Few interventions reported an exercise type and dose consistent with the WHO guidelines (aerobic: 1.6%, muscle strengthening: 5.6%, both: 1.6%). Poor reporting of exercise intensity limited our ability to determine whether interventions met the guidelines. Conclusion: Few interventions tested in clinical trials for people with CLBP prescribe an exercise type and dose consistent with the WHO guidelines. Therefore, they do not appear sufficiently dosed to achieve broader health outcomes. Future trials should investigate the effect of WHO guideline-recommended exercise interventions on patient-reported outcomes (pain and disability) as well as health-related outcomes in people with CLBP. Impact: This exploratory analysis showed the lack of exercise interventions in the CLBP literature that meet the WHO’s physical activity guidelines. With people in chronic pain groups, such as people with CLBP, being at higher risk for noncommunicable disease, it appears this is a key consideration for exercise practitioners when designing interventions for people with CLBP.

16 December 2024 in Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JHJill A. Hayden
Jill A. Hayden
RORachel Ogilvie
Rachel Ogilvie
SKShazia Kashif
Shazia Kashif
JWJack Wilkinson
Jack Wilkinson
Reliable, well-conducted, and adequately reported research is essential for decision-making. This study uses an exploratory clustering approach to identify patterns (subgroups) of trials based on research conduct and reporting characteristics to better understand heterogeneity. Describing features of these subgroups may help elucidate mechanisms of poor planning and reporting that can be acted upon by the research community to improve the research practices. Estimating the impact of trials from specific subgroup classes on pooled treatment effects and overall certainty of evidence may inform conduct and interpretation of systematic reviews in the future. Our study used data from 456 randomized controlled trials eligible for our recent update of a Cochrane review, Exercise treatment for chronic low back pain, to explore groups of trials that have various characteristic patterns of research planning, conduct, reporting, and publication. Using latent class analysis, we explored the patterns that exist in 43 characteristics of trial planning, conduct, reporting, and publication characteristics. We identified a 4-class model as the best fit for the data; classes were labeled based on the patterns of characteristics that emerged: (1) Well Resourced & Thorough, 155 trials (34%); (2) Dated, 92 trials (20%); (3) Fundamental Deficiencies, 102 trials (22%); and (4) Research Waste, 107 trials (24%). The characteristics that best differentiated the classes were trial registration status, institution/ethics board approval, conflict of interest reported, and reporting of adverse events. There were no significant differences for estimates of treatment effect in the four classes for all comparisons of treatments with pain intensity outcomes; two classes overestimated functional limitations outcomes for exercise compared to no trial treatment and compared to other conservative treatments. Using a single characteristic to define quality or trustworthiness is no longer sufficient; individual 'problematic' characteristics could be found in all four classes. This novel research could be used as a framework for further exploration of research integrity issues in the health sciences, and the development of interventions to improve our evidence-base, taking into consideration the research motivations and means of trialists.