15 March 2022 in ICES Journal of Marine Science
Target and limit reference points are fundamental management components used to define sustainable harvest strategies. Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY) and the precautionary principle underpin many reference points. Non-proxy reference points based on MSY in age-based single-species assessments depend on the stock–recruitment (SR) relationship, which can display complex variability. Current reference points ignore persistent dynamic change by assuming that the SR relationship is stationary and with constant recruitment parameters over selected time periods. We highlight Peterman's productivity method (PPM), which is capable of tracking temporal dynamics of recruitment productivity via time-varying SR parameters. We show how temporal variability in SR parameters affects fishing mortality and biomass MSY-based reference points. Implementation of PPM allows for integrated dynamic ecosystem influences in tactical management while avoiding overwrought and sometimes ephemeral mechanistic hypotheses tested on small and variable SR datasets. While some of these arguments have been made in individual papers, in our opinion the method has not yet garnered the attention that is due to it.
12 July 2021 in Fish and Fisheries
For many environmental indicators, the sustainable status can change because of changes in either the monitored state or the policy goal. Fisheries provide an intensively monitored setting to investigate the relative impacts of such change. Key fisheries sustainability indicators comprise the ratio between fishing pressure or biomass and their respective reference levels. We developed a retrospective database of population status, reference point changes and reported reasons for changes for all data‐rich stocks in the ICES region. We derived methods to distinguish the impacts of either source of change (monitored state or policy goal) on sustainable status. We found that reference points changed frequently (64% of populations had reference point changes) with varying magnitudes. Contrary to expectation, reference point changes were often not compensated by changes in the state thus significantly impacting inferred sustainability status and dependent scientific advice. Across a range of life histories and assessments, changes in reference points dominate retrospective revisions in status over the full time series. Overall, status before and after the change of reference point had no significant directional differences that would suggest reference point change effecting movement towards or away from sustainability. Although multiple factors have contributed to reference point changes, our results show that the reference point definition and the technical basis for estimation were the most important reasons for change. Recognizing that reference points are not constant in time but rather form reference series is paramount to quantifying present and historical sustainability. Properly documenting, justifying and quantifying the impacts of such change is an ongoing challenge.
26 September 2023 in ICES Journal of Marine Science
The Celtic Seas ecoregion (CSE) is undergoing climatic and ecosystem changes, which can induce changes in fish productivity. Globally, the productivity of many stocks has shown evidence of change over decadal timescales. Varying factors might drive these dynamics in the CSE, but for many stocks, these mechanisms have not been fully understood to be included in management advice. We study dynamic productivity for 28 stocks in the Celtic Seas by tracking integrated stochastic signals in the relationship between stock size and recruitment using state-space modelling applying Peterman’s Productivity Method. Our research objectives were to (i) fit Ricker stock–recruitment models with time-varying parameters to all age- or length-based assessed stocks in the CSE, (ii) evaluate which parameters vary in time, (iii) examine temporal characteristics of historical recruitment productivity, and (iv) evaluate productivity correlation across stocks. For 22 out of 28 stocks, at least one of the three time-varying parameter models had a better fit than the time-invariant model. In the CSE, fish productivity has diverse temporal patterns, with some stocks displaying relevant long-term decreasing productivity trends. Getting insight into temporal changes in recruitment productivity is very valuable and has important implications for sustainable fisheries.