17 August 2022 in International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health
Objective: For the general working population, robust evidence exists for associations between psychosocial work exposures and mental health. As this relationship is less clear for young workers, this systematic review aims at providing an overview of the evidence concerning psychosocial work factors affecting mental health of young workers. Methods: The electronic databases used were PubMed, Web of Science, and PsycINFO and were last searched in October 2021. The eligible outcomes included depression-, stress-, burnout- and anxiety-related complaints, and fatigue, excluding clinical diagnoses and suicide-related outcomes. Only studies with workers aged 35 years or younger were included, which reported at least one association between a psychosocial work factor as exposure and a mental health complaint as outcome. Studies had to be in English, German or Dutch. Risk of bias was assessed using an instrument from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Data synthesis was conducted using GRADE. Results: In total 17 studies were included in this systematic review, including data from 35,600 young workers in total. Across these studies 86 exposure-outcome associations were reported. Nine exposure-outcome associations could be synthesised. The application of the GRADE framework led to one “low” assessment for the association between psychosocial job quality and mental health. The certainty of evidence for the other eight associations in the synthesis was very low. Conclusions: The current systematic review disclosed a high degree of uncertainty of the evidence due to conceptually fuzzy outcomes and exposures as well as large heterogeneity between studies.
18 October 2023 in BMJ Open
Objectives This study aims to assess the heterogeneity of psychosocial working conditions of young workers by identifying subgroups of work characteristic configurations within young workers and to assess these subgroups’ associations with emotional exhaustion. Design Latent class analysis. Groups were formed based on 12 work characteristics (8 job demands and 4 job resources), educational level and sex. Differences in emotional exhaustion between subgroups were analysed using analysis of variance and post hoc comparisons. Setting Data from the 2019 wave of the Netherlands Working Conditions Survey. Participants 7301 individuals between the age of 18 and 30 years, who worked more than 16 hours per week. Main outcome measure Emotional exhaustion. Results Five subgroups of work characteristics could be identified and were labelled as: (1) ‘low-complexity work’ (24.4%), (2) ‘office work’ (32.3%), (3) ‘manual and non-interpersonal work’ (12.4%), (4) ‘non-manual and interpersonal work’ (21.0%), and (5) ‘manual and interpersonal work’ (9.9%). Mean scores for emotional exhaustion in the two interpersonal work groups (M=3.11, SD=1.4; M=3.45, SD=1.6) were significantly higher than in the first three groups (M=2.05, SD=1.1; M=1.98, SD=1.0; M=2.05, SD=1.1) (all 95% CIs excluding 0). Further, mean scores for emotional exhaustion were significantly higher in the ‘manual and interpersonal work’ group than in the ‘non-manual and interpersonal work’ group (95% CI 0.24, 0.45). All results could be replicated in the 2017 and 2021 waves of the Netherlands Working Conditions Survey. Conclusions Young workers reported heterogeneous work characteristic configurations with substantial differences in degrees of emotional exhaustion between the identified subgroups. Preventing emotional exhaustion should focus on the two interpersonal work subgroups, which showed a high degree of emotional exhaustion. In prevention efforts, these groups’ configurations of work characteristics should be taken into account.
29 November 2024 in BMC Public Health
Background: The evidence base for the relationship between psychosocial work factors and mental health focuses primarily on the general working population but little is known about young workers. The aim of this qualitative study is to identify psychosocial work factors that affect the mental health of young workers, with a focus on (1) novel factors of the psychosocial work environment that are relevant for young workers but have not been described in the literature and (2) experiences of psychosocial work factors associated with mental health that are specific to and typical for young workers. Methods: Semi-structured interviews were held with 36 workers aged up to 30. Participants were asked to describe work situations that affected their mental health. Factors were identified using a combination of inductive and deductive coding and open-coded factors were mapped onto the Copenhagen Psychosocial Questionnaire (COPSOQ), which is widely used as a framework for psychosocial work factors. Results: Most of the psychosocial factors mentioned by the young workers could be mapped onto the COPSOQ framework and were therefore similar to the general working population. Novel factors identified by this study were “Procedural support” and “Responsibility for others”. We also identified young-worker-specific experiences of psychosocial work factors associated with mental health (i.e. Quantitative Demands, Influence at Work, Commitment to the Workplace, Job Insecurity, Quality of work, Job satisfaction, and Vertical Trust). Lastly, young workers did not report the COPSOQ factor Insecurity over working conditions and Work-life conflict was reported as an indicator of mental health status rather than being perceived as a factor of the psychosocial work environment. Conclusions: Psychosocial work factors and their influence on mental health reported by young workers in this qualitative study are comparable to what is reported for the general working population. There are however some young-worker-specific experiences of psychosocial work factors and two novel factors. The novel factors, “Procedural support” and “Responsibility for others” are not found in common psychosocial work factor frameworks and might be studied specifically in relation to young workers. Our results provide organisations with levers that can be used to create a psychosocial work environment that benefits the mental health of young workers.
12 November 2025 in BMJ Open
Objectives Being exposed to adverse psychosocial working conditions contributes to poor mental health in young workers. This study explores whether psychosocial work adversities are a necessary condition for work-related emotional exhaustion in young workers. Design Data from the ‘Netherlands Working Condition Survey 2021’ was used. By applying a novel method called Necessary Condition Analysis, we tested two psychosocial work adversities as necessary conditions for high work-related emotional exhaustion in young workers: (1) a composite score of high job demands and low job resources and (2) a composite score of high job demands. Additionally, we tested whether the threshold for job demands as a necessary condition for high work-related emotional exhaustion differed for young workers with low versus high resources. Setting Secondary data analysis on a national working population-based survey. Participants The sample included 5791 young workers in the Netherlands (aged <30 years; 56.8% female). Primary outcome measure Work-related emotional exhaustion. Results A high level of the composite on job demands and job resources is necessary for a high level of work-related emotional exhaustion in young workers (effect size=0.11, p<0.001), and the same applies to the composite score of high job demands alone (effect size=0.10, p<0.001). The necessity threshold for job demands, which guarantees the absence of a particularly high level of work-related emotional exhaustion, was higher for the group of young workers with high job resources compared with young workers with low job resources. Conclusions Both psychosocial work adversities were necessary conditions for high work-related emotional exhaustion in young workers. The necessity threshold for job demands was higher for young workers with high job resources, compared with the group with low resources. This indicates that removing psychosocial work adversities and ensuring the presence of job resources might contribute to the prevention of high work-related emotional exhaustion in young workers.
1 March 2026 in Gedrag & Organisatie
Samenvatting Zelfgerapporteerde burn-outklachten blijken vooral onder jongere werknemers toegenomen. Om aanknopingspunten te vinden voor de aanpak hiervan is meer inzicht nodig in de heterogeniteit binnen deze groep met betrekking tot deze klachten. Dit onderzoek richt zich op verschillen in burn-outklachten onder jonge werknemers, en op factoren die daarbij een rol spelen. Met de Nationale Enquête Arbeidsomstandigheden van TNO/CBS hebben we onderzocht (1) hoe burn-outklachten zich sinds 2014 bij jonge werknemers hebben ontwikkeld, opgesplitst naar opleidingsniveau, en (2) welke verbanden er zijn tussen enerzijds verschillende achtergrond- en werkkenmerken en anderzijds burn-outklachten bij jonge werknemers in het algemeen, alsook (3) binnen subgroepen op basis van opleidingsniveau. Resultaten laten een stijgende trend in burn-outklachten voor alle opleidingsniveaus zien. Ook blijkt dat er binnen de groep jonge werknemers risicogroepen zijn, onder andere op basis van geslacht, leeftijd en opleidingsniveau. Maar vooral werkkenmerken zoals ervaren baanonzekerheid, hoge taakeisen en weinig autonomie blijken een belangrijke rol te spelen bij het verklaren van verschillen in burn-outklachten. Ook zien wij dat hogere taakeisen een sterkere samenhang met burn-outklachten hebben bij middelbaar opgeleiden dan bij hoger opgeleiden. Psychosociale werkkenmerken vormen daarom belangrijke aanknopingspunten voor interventies gericht op het voorkomen dan wel verminderen van burn-outklachten onder jongere werknemers.