1 October 2021 in The Surgeon
11 April 2026 in Bone & Joint Open
Aims: This audit aimed to assess compliance with British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma (BOAST) for paediatric forearm and wrist fractures across UK NHS hospitals and identify targets for improvement locally and nationally. Methods: This was a prospective, multicentre observational audit of BOAST standards for the Early Management of the Paediatric Forearm Fracture guideline. Consecutive patients aged under 16 years presenting with a forearm or distal radius fracture over a two-month period were included with follow-up to eight weeks post injury. Data were collected to assess each of the BOAST standards for practice. Percentage compliance with all standards was calculated for each hospital. Results: Data from 1,699 patients across 53 hospitals were included. The mean age was 9.7 years (SD 3.6), and 37% (n = 636) were female. Overall, 60% of fractures (n = 1,023) were metaphyseal distal radius fractures. A total of 577 patients (34%) underwent manipulation with the majority initially reduced in the Emergency Department (ED) (n = 423, 73%); 89 (21%) required subsequent theatre manipulation. The median time to first manipulation in the ED was two hours 43 minutes (IQR 1 hr 43 mins to 4 hrs 4 mins) and 18 hours 47 minutes (IQR 13 hrs 48 mins to 24 hrs 2 mins) when first manipulation was performed in theatre. Overall compliance with BOAST standards was 63%, with 20% of patients (n = 85) having pain scores documented, 51% (n = 217) having a complete neurovascular assessment, and 23% (n = 95) receiving analgesia and a patient information leaflet on discharge. Conclusion: This study highlights variability in managing paediatric fractures despite established standards. In line with recommendations, a high proportion of reductions are now being performed in EDs. Particular areas requiring improvement are the management of paediatric pain, documented assessment of neurovascular status, and the provision of patient information. We recommend that hospitals review their current practice and ensure that local protocols are in place to promote the provision of optimal care for this patient group, and to minimize the impact on operating theatre capacity. Cite this article: Bone Jt Open 2026;7(4):531–539.
25 February 2026 in The Knee
Paediatric ACL injuries are increasingly common and present significant challenges. Inappropriate treatment can lead to long-term complications like instability, growth disturbance, and osteoarthritis. The Paediatric ACL National Audit (PANA) Study assesses UK practices and adherence to Best Orthopaedic Practice (BOAST) guidelines for managing these injuries, identifying opportunities to improve care for young patients. PANA was a collaborative audit of 22 hospitals in England, Wales, and Scotland, measuring adherence to BOAST guidelines in treating paediatric ACL injuries. Orthopaedic surgeons and trainees collected data through a secure online questionnaire about service provision for skeletally immature patients, including diagnostic imaging, rehabilitation, post-operative follow-up, and surgical techniques. Our analysis revealed variability in adherence to the BOAST guidelines for ACL injuries in paediatric patients, with 65% of centres using acute knee pathways and 68% utilising collaborative imaging pathways. About 59% of centres conduct radiological growth monitoring, while only 30% report functional outcomes. Less than 50% report re-rupture rates, and 74% adhere to rehabilitation protocols. The rise in ACL injuries in the paediatric population highlights the need for standardised care delivery and reporting. Following the release of the BOAST guidelines in 2022, this nationwide audit has revealed discrepancies in UK practices. A multidisciplinary approach is essential for improving patient care and outcomes by standardising and promoting best practice.
1 September 2021 in British Journal of Surgery
OCOn behalf of the RoboSurg Collaborative
On behalf of the RoboSurg Collaborative
+3
Background: Robot-assisted cholecystectomy (RC) has seen increasing adoption into clinical practice despite a lack of evidence to demonstrate superiority over conventional methods. Consistency in outcome selection, definition and reporting between studies is required for effective evidence synthesis and to minimise research waste. The aim of this study was to conduct an in-depth analysis of the outcomes reported in studies of RC. This work will inform the need for a core outcome set (COS). Method: Systematic searches identified all published studies reporting RC, from inception to February 2020. Outcomes reported in each manuscript were recorded verbatim and categorised into domains. All outcomes were coded in duplicate. Where reported, the follow up period of each study was documented. Results: Of 1425 abstracts screened, ninety studies met the criteria for inclusion. A total of 878 outcomes were reported. Each study included a median of 8 outcomes (range 3-26). Outcome selection was heterogeneous, with those relating to technical/operative factors (n = 383, 88 studies), complications (n = 245, 81 studies) and health economics (n = 139, 72 studies) used most frequently. No single outcome, or outcome domain, was reported in all studies. Only 30 studies reported a follow-up period, which ranged from 14 days to 46 months. In thirteen, the follow-up was for less than or equal to one month. Conclusions: We identified significant heterogeneity in the selection and reporting of outcomes in studies of RC and support calls for standardisation and development of a COS.