1 February 2020 in IET Software
The low performance of software projects generally arises from erroneous, omitted, misinterpreted, or conflicting requirements. To produce better quality specifications, the practise of requirements reuse through requirement patterns has been widely debated in the secondary literature. However, a tertiary study that provides an overview of secondary studies on the state of the art and the practise of requirement patterns does not exist. This study describes a study of secondary literature on requirement patterns under a perspective on research and practise. The identification and selection methods of secondary studies include automatic search on five sources, inclusion, and exclusion criteria, the snowballing technique, and the quality assessment of those studies. Four secondary studies are considered relevant according to the purpose of this research from a 26‐distinct‐study group. The authors’ contribution is two‐fold: the tertiary study itself and a preliminary research agenda dealing with state of the art and practise on requirement patterns.
1 June 2022 in Requirements Engineering
28 May 2025 in Journal of Software Engineering Research and Development
Context: In the last decade, machine learning (ML) components have become more and more present in contemporary software systems. A number of secondary literature studies reports challenges impacting on the development of ML-based systems, including those for requirements engineering (RE) activities. Motivation/Problem: Synthesizing secondary literature contributes to building knowledge and reaching conclusions about the existing RE approaches for ML-based systems (RE4ML), besides the novelty of a tertiary study on that subject. Objective: Through a tertiary study protocol we elaborated on, this paper synthesizes the body of evidence present in secondary studies on RE4ML systems. Method: We followed well-accepted guidelines about tertiary study protocols, including automatic search, the snowballing technique, selection and quality criteria, and data extraction and synthesis. Results: Nine secondary studies on RE4ML systems were aligned to our tertiary study's goal. We extracted and summarized the requirements elicitation, analysis, specification, validation, and management techniques for ML-based systems as well as the great challenges identified. Finally, we contribute with a nine-item research agenda to direct current and future searches to fill the gaps found. Conclusions: We conclude that RE has not been left aside in ML research, however, there are still challenges to be overcome, such as dealing with non-functional requirements, collaboration between stakeholders, and research in an industrial environment.
29 April 2022 in Journal of Software Engineering Research and Development
Conducting systematic studies during a postgraduate program, such as systematic review, systematic mapping, and tertiary review, can benefit the project’s success. They provide an overview of the literature considering currently available research findings, establish baselines for other research activities, and support decisions made throughout the research project. However, there is a shortage of research that presents systematic studies experiences in supporting academic projects. This paper’s main contribution is reporting our experience on how the evidence found in tertiary and secondary studies positively influenced a PhD project’s decisions. Initially, a tertiary study was conducted, followed by a systematic mapping. The evidence returned by the tertiary study led to the definition of the PhD research proposal in the Requirement Engineering field. Moreover, a systematic mapping contributed to the definition of the PhD research problem. From this experience in undertaking systematic studies to support a PhD project, the paper also presents lessons learned and recommendations to guide PhD students’ decisions.