The global shortage of fish meal (FM) presents a significant challenge to the sustainability of aquaculture and the aquafeed industry. Consequently, numerous studies have investigated alternative ingredients to replace FM in fish feed. However, the use of novel feed ingredients may pose risks not only to farmed fish but also to human consumers, particularly due to the potential accumulation of metals and metalloids in fish tissues. In this study, four experimental diets for common carp (Cyprinus carpio) were formulated using different animal protein sources: fish meal, earthworm meal, mealworm meal, and zooplankton meal. A 12-week feeding trial was conducted with juvenile (1+) carp under two rearing systems: (1) intensive (laboratory tanks), and (2) semi-intensive (earthen pond). The aim of the study was to determine the concentrations of harmful elements (Pb, As, Cr, Cu, Fe, Li, Zn, Ni, Mn, Cd, Co, Al, Sr) in carp fillets and to assess potential risks for consumers. Additionally, the study compares the effects of different protein sources and rearing systems on element accumulation.