22 June 2020 in Optics Express
GPGuillermo Peris-Fajarnés
The strip comparison method, based on the serial exploration method described by Torgerson [Theory and Methods of Scaling; Wiley & Sons (1958); Chap. 7], for the development of near-threshold color difference models was presented and validated with theoretical data by the authors in a previous work. In this study, we investigate parametric effects derived from the use of the strip comparison method on chromaticity-discrimination ellipses around the red CIE color center. The results obtained led to the conclusion that the strip comparison method has little effect on the parameters of the chromaticity-discrimination ellipses determined by the pair comparison method when pairs of patches in the strips are separated by a black line 0.5 mm thick or are separated by 3 mm spacing on a white background and also correlates well with the parameters reported by other authors using the pair comparison method at the threshold.
2 July 2020 in Optics Express
GPGuillermo Peris-Fajarnés
This paper presents a method for developing color-difference models near a threshold, based on the serial exploration method described by Torgerson [Theory and Methods of Scaling; Wiley & Sons (1958); Chap. 7], involving the construction of color-control strips of patches arranged in arrays of 2 × n, where n is the number of pairs in the strip. The patches in the lower row should be calorimetrically identical, while the color of the patches in the upper row should vary progressively in constant steps of CIELAB color difference along selected color space vector directions. Prospective observers are instructed to indicate the patch pair number for which they begin to perceive a slight color difference between corresponding patches. The frequency data obtained from the observers was used to build a threshold color-difference model. The intention was to validate the method with theoretical data to determine the effect of the precision with which the strips are constructed, on the accuracy of the estimated parameters. Theoretical frequency data was generated using the CIE94 color difference formula, whose associated color discrimination ellipsoid parameters are very easy to determine, associated with a hypothetical logistic psychometric curve for different color centers. The proposed method allows to determine color discrimination parameters with a precision nearby 4% and an accuracy of 3% with respect to the simulated theoretical parameters, for color samples generated with a standard deviation of $\Delta E_{ab}^\ast{=} 0.2$ of the superimposed error around the ideal color difference of pairs of patches.
12 March 2019 in Journal of the Optical Society of America A
Results from different authors showed deviations of radial orientation in the plane (tilt) for the major axes of chromaticity-discrimination ellipses centered around the International Commission on Illumination (CIE) red color center [Color Res. Appl. 3, 149 (1978)], which are not considered by most of the current advanced color-difference formulas (e.g., CIEDE2000). We performed a visual experiment using red printed samples in order to test the influence of the separation between samples (gap) on the mentioned tilt. Our results confirm a counterclockwise tilt of fitted ellipses with a magnitude of approximately 36° for samples with no separation, which is similar to that detected by other authors, and a reduction of the mentioned tilt owing to the separation of the samples. We detected a tilt of approximately 22° for samples with a black gap of 0.5 mm and a tilt of approximately 25° for samples with a white gap of 3 mm. Notably, the uncertainty of previous values given by the corresponding credibility intervals of 95% posterior probability is approximately of the mean values. Finally, we study the performance of the most widely used color-difference formulas in the graphic arts sector using our current experimental results, and conclude that the performance of the CAM02-SCD and CAM02-UCS color-difference formulas is significantly better than that of the CIEDE2000 formula.
3 August 2021 in Optics Express
JRJimena González-Del Río
A Bayesian approach alternative to the one used in the strip-pair comparison method for developing threshold color-difference models is presented in this paper. Strip-pair comparison method is based on the construction of color-control strips made of pairs of patches put in contact and ordered by increasing the CIELAB color difference. Observers are required to indicate the number of the pair of patches in every strip for which they begin to perceive a just noticeable color difference. Frequency data obtained, from repeating several times the visual assessment, is recorded to build a Bayesian multinomial logistic regression model, which allows the determination of the coefficients of the color discrimination ellipsoids. The results of the Bayesian approach agree closely with the results obtained to validate strip-pair comparison method for the same theoretical frequency data. The main advantage of the Bayesian approach over many other methods is that it allows a direct analysis of the statistical variability of the estimated parameters by means of confidence intervals and other measures of statistical variability.