This chapter documents educators’ first-hand experiences of teaching science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) subjects online during the COVID-19 pandemic and we explore what lies at the interface between human experience and the pedagogy of complex, abstract STEM concepts online. Experiences of how the move to an online mode of delivery impacted on the teaching of these STEM educators as they dealt first-hand with the realities of teaching complex, abstract concepts (e.g., Calculus) online are drawn from open-ended questions in an online survey with STEM educators from secondary schools and universities who had taught STEM content using technological apps, tools and services online during this time. Extracting themes raised by these educators, we integrate them within this “new [ab]normal” into meaningful and topical vignettes about emerging teaching practices for STEM educators. In this chapter we also discuss how theories of learning do not address learning that occurs outside of people (i.e., learning that is influenced and manipulated by technologies) and how connectivism provides a new perspective on networked learning within education. This cycle of networked knowledge development potentially allows individuals to remain up to date in their domain through the connections they form. Findings show that this process has not yet advanced to a suitable stage of development and that teaching complex STEM concepts online may still require a substantial measure of face-to-face facilitation.