2 January 2014 in SpringerPlus
Background: Surgery for pelvic organ prolapse is a common surgical procedure. There is little research studying post-operative pain, contrasting with extensive literature on pain after childbirth trauma which shows that suture method has a significant effect on pain. We designed a protocol for a trial comparing suture techniques and post-operative pain, and conducted a pre-protocol pilot to inform our trial design. Methods: Routine surgical data, post-operative pain scores (from 10 cm Visual Analogue Scales, VAS) and analgesic requirements were obtained from the notes of a cohort of women undergoing vaginal prolapse surgery. Median VAS scores at 4, 12 and 24 hours were compared by suture material used and method of closure (single continuous suture or interrupted sutures). The women whose data were obtained were invited to attend focus groups of up to six people in the twelve weeks following surgery. A semi structured question guide was used, and interviews were recorded, transcribed anonymously and analysed using the constant comparative method of grounded theory. Ethical approval was not sought because formal pre-protocol work is exempt for UK ethical requirements, but formal written consent on standard forms was obtained for publishing outcomes and anonymised comments from participants. Results: Complete VAS data and operative details were available from 41 women. Surgery was completed using absorbable polyglactin sutures with continuous suturing (17 women) or interrupted sutures (24 women). Pain scores at 4 and 12 hours were similar; pain at 24 hours was greater in the women with interrupted sutures (median VAS 3 (range 0–8) versus 1.5 (0–8) (p = 0.0513). Analgesic needs were similar. Two focus groups (nine participants) revealed that women regarded post-operative pain as insignificant and not a topic worthy of formal research. It was apparent that the use, and especially removal of, vaginal packs was a practice associated with pain which women remembered as a significant part of their post-operative experience. Conclusions: Formal pre-protocol work is informative; we found a moderate difference in our proposed outcomes, suggesting a trial was feasible but women themselves were unconvinced of the need for formal research into pain following vaginal surgery.
1 September 2012 in European Urology
1 January 2005 in European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology
1 February 2007 in Obstetrics & Gynecology
To compare the quality of data recorded in urinary diaries completed for 3 days compared with those completed for 7 days. Men and women enrolled in a randomized study of a nurse-led intervention for urinary incontinence were eligible for the study. Participants completed either a 7-day diary or a 3-day diary at baseline and after 8 weeks of the trial intervention. Data quality was assessed by categorizing each day as complete or incomplete. Incomplete days were those with fewer than four entries and those with obvious discrepancies from the rest of the diary days. Data were compared by percentage differences with 95% confidence intervals (95% CI). Two hundred forty-eight patients completed the 3-day diary, and 40 patients competed the 7-day diary. The majority of the respondents were women. There were more completed 3-day diaries (90.7%) compared with 7-day diaries (50%) (difference 40.7%, 95% CI 28.8-52.6%). When compared with the first 3 days of the 7-day diary, the 3-day diary contained more complete data (90.7% versus 65%; difference 25.7%, 95% CI 14.6-36.9%). These differences were seen in all data types except nocturnal incontinence. There was no evidence of association between diary completion and demographic characteristics. Our data demonstrated that the 7-day diary included less complete data than the 3-day diary, even in the first 3 days of the longer diary. This finding suggests elements of both diary "fatigue" and also diary "despair" may be acting. We would suggest that a 3-day diary is superior in terms of data quality. III.
19 October 2012 in International Urogynecology Journal