Machine learning-driven clinical decision support systems (ML-CDSSs) seem impressively promising for future routine and emergency care. However, reflection on their clinical implementation reveals a wide array of ethical challenges. The preferences, concerns and expectations of professional stakeholders remain largely unexplored. Empirical research, however, may help to clarify the conceptual debate and its aspects in terms of their relevance for clinical practice. This study explores, from an ethical point of view, future healthcare professionals’ attitudes to potential changes of responsibility and decision-making authority when using ML-CDSS. Twenty-seven semistructured interviews were conducted with German medical students and nursing trainees. The data were analysed based on qualitative content analysis according to Kuckartz. Interviewees’ reflections are presented under three themes the interviewees describe as closely related: (self-)attribution of responsibility, decision-making authority and need of (professional) experience. The results illustrate the conceptual interconnectedness of professional responsibility and its structural and epistemic preconditions to be able to fulfil clinicians’ responsibility in a meaningful manner. The study also sheds light on the four relata of responsibility understood as a relational concept. The article closes with concrete suggestions for the ethically sound clinical implementation of ML-CDSS.
23 August 2024 in Journal of Medical Internet Research
Background: Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) are increasingly being introduced into various domains of health care. Little is known so far about the impact of such systems on the health care professional–patient relationship, and there is a lack of agreement about whether and how patients should be informed about the use of CDSSs. Objective: This study aims to explore, in an empirically informed manner, the potential implications for the health care professional–patient relationship and to underline the importance of this relationship when using CDSSs for both patients and future professionals. Methods: Using a methodological triangulation, 15 medical students and 12 trainee nurses were interviewed in semistructured interviews and 18 patients were involved in focus groups between April 2021 and April 2022. All participants came from Germany. Three examples of CDSSs covering different areas of health care (ie, surgery, nephrology, and intensive home care) were used as stimuli in the study to identify similarities and differences regarding the use of CDSSs in different fields of application. The interview and focus group transcripts were analyzed using a structured qualitative content analysis. Results: From the interviews and focus groups analyzed, three topics were identified that interdependently address the interactions between patients and health care professionals: (1) CDSSs and their impact on the roles of and requirements for health care professionals, (2) CDSSs and their impact on the relationship between health care professionals and patients (including communication requirements for shared decision-making), and (3) stakeholders’ expectations for patient education and information about CDSSs and their use. Conclusions: The results indicate that using CDSSs could restructure established power and decision-making relationships between (future) health care professionals and patients. In addition, respondents expected that the use of CDSSs would involve more communication, so they anticipated an increased time commitment. The results shed new light on the existing discourse by demonstrating that the anticipated impact of CDSSs on the health care professional–patient relationship appears to stem less from the function of a CDSS and more from its integration in the relationship. Therefore, the anticipated effects on the relationship between health care professionals and patients could be specifically addressed in patient information about the use of CDSSs.
Background: Patients are confronted with the digital transformation of medicine, yet there is a paucity of studies that discuss the patient perspective on AI-based clinical decision support systems (AI-CDSS). Our study addresses this research gap by focusing on their needs and concerns, especially regarding trust, responsibility, and self-determination. Methods: The qualitative study was conducted between April 2021 and April 2022 with 18 patients from Germany to participate in three focus groups (5–7 per group). The groups were presented with AI-CDSS examples (surgery, nephrology, and home-ventilated care) to discuss ethical and social aspects of their implementation. The interviews were analyzed in accordance with the structured qualitative content analysis of Kuckartz and Rädiker (2022). Results: The interviewees expressed considerable uncertainty regarding the AI-CDSS implementation. The results highlight the patients’ perspective of AI-CDSS as a supportive tool or as a second opinion, which could challenge long-held values of trust, responsibility, and self-determination, particularly the relationship between trust and responsibility may undergo a transformation, leading to a loss of both. Conclusion: The findings demonstrate that patients perceive the AI-CDSS implementation as a challenge both for their own decision-making and for the future doctor-patient relationship. This is further indicated by the shifts of trust, responsibility, and self-determination as influencing decision-making factors. Concurrently, the findings show that the patients’ perspective is profoundly influenced by the individuals’ comprehension of the functionality of AI-CDSS. It is therefore of importance to provide patients and healthcare professionals with information to prevent indecision.
9 August 2024 in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
Bioethics has developed approaches to address ethical issues in health care, similar to how technology ethics provides guidelines for ethical research on artificial intelligence, big data, and robotic applications. As these digital technologies are increasingly used in medicine, health care and public health, thus, it is plausible that the approaches of technology ethics have influenced bioethical research. Similar to the “empirical turn” in bioethics, which led to intense debates about appropriate moral theories, ethical frameworks and meta-ethics due to the increased use of empirical methodologies from social sciences, the proliferation of health-related subtypes of technology ethics might have a comparable impact on current bioethical research. This systematic journal review analyses the reporting of ethical frameworks and non-empirical methods in argument-based research articles on digital technologies in medicine, health care and public health that have been published in high-impact bioethics journals. We focus on articles reporting non-empirical research in original contributions. Our aim is to describe currently used methods for the ethical analysis of ethical issues regarding the application of digital technologies in medicine, health care and public health. We confine our analysis to non-empirical methods because empirical methods have been well-researched elsewhere. Finally, we discuss our findings against the background of established methods for health technology assessment, the lack of a typology for non-empirical methods as well as conceptual and methodical change in bioethics. Our descriptive results may serve as a starting point for reflecting on whether current ethical frameworks and non-empirical methods are appropriate to research ethical issues deriving from the application of digital technologies in medicine, health care and public health.
BACKGROUND Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) are increasingly being introduced into various domains of health care. Little is known so far about the impact of such systems on the health care professional–patient relationship, and there is a lack of agreement about whether and how patients should be informed about the use of CDSSs. OBJECTIVE This study aims to explore, in an empirically informed manner, the potential implications for the health care professional–patient relationship and to underline the importance of this relationship when using CDSSs for both patients and future professionals. METHODS Using a methodological triangulation, 15 medical students and 12 trainee nurses were interviewed in semistructured interviews and 18 patients were involved in focus groups between April 2021 and April 2022. All participants came from Germany. Three examples of CDSSs covering different areas of health care (ie, surgery, nephrology, and intensive home care) were used as stimuli in the study to identify similarities and differences regarding the use of CDSSs in different fields of application. The interview and focus group transcripts were analyzed using a structured qualitative content analysis. RESULTS From the interviews and focus groups analyzed, three topics were identified that interdependently address the interactions between patients and health care professionals: (1) CDSSs and their impact on the roles of and requirements for health care professionals, (2) CDSSs and their impact on the relationship between health care professionals and patients (including communication requirements for shared decision-making), and (3) stakeholders’ expectations for patient education and information about CDSSs and their use. CONCLUSIONS The results indicate that using CDSSs could restructure established power and decision-making relationships between (future) health care professionals and patients. In addition, respondents expected that the use of CDSSs would involve more communication, so they anticipated an increased time commitment. The results shed new light on the existing discourse by demonstrating that the anticipated impact of CDSSs on the health care professional–patient relationship appears to stem less from the function of a CDSS and more from its integration in the relationship. Therefore, the anticipated effects on the relationship between health care professionals and patients could be specifically addressed in patient information about the use of CDSSs.