22 March 2016 in Risk Analysis
1 September 2015 in Royal Society Open Science
The scientific understanding of the driving factors behind zoonotic and pandemic influenzas is hampered by complex interactions between viruses, animal hosts and humans. This complexity makes identifying influenza viruses of high zoonotic or pandemic risk, before they emerge from animal populations, extremely difficult and uncertain. As a first step towards assessing zoonotic risk of influenza, we demonstrate a risk assessment framework to assess the relative likelihood of influenza A viruses, circulating in animal populations, making the species jump into humans. The intention is that such a risk assessment framework could assist decision-makers to compare multiple influenza viruses for zoonotic potential and hence to develop appropriate strain-specific control measures. It also provides a first step towards showing proof of principle for an eventual pandemic risk model. We show that the spatial and temporal epidemiology is as important in assessing the risk of an influenza A species jump as understanding the innate molecular capability of the virus. We also demonstrate data deficiencies that need to be addressed in order to consistently combine both epidemiological and molecular virology data into a risk assessment framework.
29 March 2017 in Royal Society Open Science
Foodborne infection is a result of exposure to complex, dynamic food systems. The efficiency of foodborne infection is driven by ongoing shifts in genetic machinery. Next-generation sequencing technologies can provide high-fidelity data about the genetics of a pathogen. However, food safety surveillance systems do not currently provide similar high-fidelity epidemiological metadata to associate with genetic data. As a consequence, it is rarely possible to transform genetic data into actionable knowledge that can be used to genuinely inform risk assessment or prevent outbreaks. Big data approaches are touted as a revolution in decision support, and pose a potentially attractive method for closing the gap between the fidelity of genetic and epidemiological metadata for food safety surveillance. We therefore developed a simple food chain model to investigate the potential benefits of combining ‘big’ data sources, including both genetic and high-fidelity epidemiological metadata. Our results suggest that, as for any surveillance system, the collected data must be relevant and characterize the important dynamics of a system if we are to properly understand risk: this suggests the need to carefully consider data curation, rather than the more ambitious claims of big data proponents that unstructured and unrelated data sources can be combined to generate consistent insight. Of interest is that the biggest influencers of foodborne infection risk were contamination load and processing temperature, not genotype. This suggests that understanding food chain dynamics would probably more effectively generate insight into foodborne risk than prescribing the hazard in ever more detail in terms of genotype.
24 June 2024 in Information Visualization
Many data visualization experts recommend the use of bar charts over pie charts because they consider comparing the area or angle of segments to be less accurate than comparing bars on a bar chart. However, many studies show that when the pie chart is used to estimate proportions (arguably its main function) it is as accurate as the bar chart. A major issue is that most previous studies have only looked at one method of extracting information from pie charts, for example either by comparing the segment to the circle (the part-whole relationship) or one segment to another (relative magnitude estimation). Therefore, in this study I test multiple metrics to provide a more holistic assessment of the pie and donut chart against the bar chart. I also measured cognitive load through pupillometry. In summary, bar charts were more precise than pie and donut charts for ranking elements, but all charts were equally accurate for extracting the part-whole relationship. There was little difference in cognitive load between chart types, although bar charts were consistently faster to use on average. Overall, the bar chart was more flexible, but where there were statistically significant differences between charts, the effect sizes were often small, and unlikely to prevent effective extraction of quantitative information. That is, as long as they were used appropriately, all chart types were arguably acceptable for displaying simple, categorical data.
10 June 2025 in Continuity & Resilience Review
Purpose: Supply chain managers must balance accuracy, timeliness and accessibility of information to make good decisions on risk, preventing or mitigating un-acceptable risks. Thus, any risk assessment method must strike a practical balance between the three. The risk matrix is popular in Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM) as it reduces complexity of more quantitative risk analyses, by categorising likelihood and impact into qualitative constructs or semi-quantitative scores. This makes SCRM much more realistic and understandable to non-quantitative risk managers. However, while it is simple and easy to use, it is also, according to a now substantial literature, not fit for purpose due to numerous mathematical flaws which are discussed in this article. Design/methodology/approach: This paper reassesses the SCRM domain when it comes to making good decisions based on increasingly complex amounts of qualitative and quantitative data. Findings: The advantages and disadvantages of both the risk matrix and Quantitative Risk Analysis (QRA) are discussed, providing some solutions for overcoming the majority of the mathematical flaws of the risk matrix. Practical implications: A more appropriate, fit-for-purpose approach toward the supply chain risk management matrix is offered. Originality/value: Often poor implementation, rather than a structural issue with the risk matrix approach is evident in practice. The criticisms of risk matrices can be overcome, producing a more reliable way to assess and manage supply chain risk.
15 February 2025 in Information Visualization
Graphical perception studies have largely focused on how accurate participants can be at extracting quantitative information from glyphs in various visualization types, including infographics. However, most studies assume that there is only one correct way to encode information, for example to compare two circles the encoding mechanism must be relative area. We suspect that this assumption is over-simplistic, especially for glyphs that have an obvious two- dimensional structure, and that some participants use relative height instead. This is a crucial, but it seems often overlooked, aspect of graphical perception studies, and indeed of data visualization in general. If participants are not using the same encoding mechanism that the designer has used, this represents a clear systematic bias that can induce large errors in viewers’ estimates. We therefore assessed which encoding mechanism was being used for several glyphs, including bars, squares, circles, triangles and human icons. We found that almost half of participants’ estimates were likely based on the encoding mechanism of relative height, not area, for all two-dimensional glyphs. A strong relationship was found between the relative size of the two glyphs being compared and the encoding mechanism used. Participants were much more likely to choose relative height if the smaller glyph was over 60% of the size of the larger glyph. In contrast for the one-dimensional glyph (bar), almost all participants chose relative height as the encoding mechanism. This study therefore shows the importance of considering what encoding mechanisms participants could use, and thus tailoring infographics and visualizations to avoid such ambiguity.