Revived interest in lunar exploration is heralding a new generation of design solutions in support of human operations on the Moon. While space system design has traditionally been guided by prototype deployments in analogue studies, the resource-intensive nature of this approach has largely precluded application of proficient user-centered design (UCD) methods from human-computer interaction (HCI). This paper explores possible use of Virtual Reality (VR) to simulate analogue studies in lab settings and thereby bring to bear UCD in this otherwise engineering-dominated field. Drawing on the ongoing development of the European Large Logistics Lander, we have recreated a prospective lunar operational scenario in VR and evaluated it with a group of astronauts and space experts (n=20). Our qualitative findings demonstrate the efficacy of VR in facilitating UCD, enabling efficient contextual inquiries and improving project team coordination. We conclude by proposing future directions to further exploit VR in lunar systems design.
Space agencies are in the process of drawing up carefully thought-out Concepts of Operations (ConOps) for future human missions on the Moon. These are typically assessed and validated through costly and logistically demanding analogue field studies. While interactive simulations in Virtual Reality (VR) offer a comparatively cost-effective alternative, they have faced criticism for lacking the fidelity of real-world deployments. This paper explores the applicability of passive haptic interfaces in bridging the gap between simulated and real-world ConOps assessments. Leveraging passive haptic props (equipment mockup and astronaut gloves), we virtually recreated the Apollo 12 mission procedure and assessed it with experienced astronauts and other space experts. Quantitative and qualitative findings indicate that haptics increased presence and embodiment, thus improving perceived simulation fidelity and validity of user reflections. We conclude by discussing the potential role of passive haptic modalities in facilitating early-stage ConOps assessments for human endeavours on the Moon and beyond.
8 January 2026 in International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction
Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) research often requires resource-intensive, safety-critical physical setups. Augmented Reality (AR) simulations could offer a viable alternative, but their validity remains unclear. To investigate this, we conducted a between-subjects study comparing trust ratings in an AR-based and a real-world handover task using a physical robotic arm. Participants (N = 40) carried out a series of handovers with the robot and experienced two types of trust violations: the robot dropping the handover-object and handing it over in an inconvenient position. Our results, analysed using Bayesian methods, showed no clear evidence for differences between the AR and physical conditions and, in some cases, even practical equivalence (in correctly executed handovers and during violations where the robot dropped the object). These findings provide initial evidence that AR-based simulations can yield trust-related results comparable to those observed in physical human–robot interactions.
Augmented reality (AR) enables simulating robots in Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) research, offering a cheaper, more accessible, and flexible alternative to complex, resource-intensive physical setups. However, the comparability of AR and physical HRI results remains unclear. In this paper, we address this question by comparing subjective workload and engagement ratings, and objective task performance in AR-simulated and physical robot settings under fatigue. Participants (N = 47) completed a collaborative assembly-and-handover task with either an AR-simulated or a physical robot. Subjective workload and engagement were comparable between environments and, for several measures (namely mental demand and perceived effort), showed practical equivalence. Objective task performance differed for some measures: reaction times and movement durations were longer in AR, whereas more errors occurred in the physical condition, while assembly duration showed equivalent results. We discuss these findings with respect to opportunities and limits to the validity of AR-simulated HRI research.