Giorgia Lorenzini

Giorgia Lorenzini

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Giorgia Lorenzini

Institute for Biomedical Ethics, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
25 March 2023 in Bioethics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
LOLaura Arbelaez Ossa
Laura Arbelaez Ossa
DSDavid Shaw
David Shaw
BEBernice Simone Elger
Bernice Simone Elger
Artificial intelligence (AI) based clinical decision support systems (CDSS) are becoming ever more widespread in healthcare and could play an important role in diagnostic and treatment processes. For this reason, AI‐based CDSS has an impact on the doctor–patient relationship, shaping their decisions with its suggestions. We may be on the verge of a paradigm shift, where the doctor–patient relationship is no longer a dual relationship, but a triad. This paper analyses the role of AI‐based CDSS for shared decision‐making to better comprehend its promises and associated ethical issues. Moreover, it investigates how certain AI implementations may instead foster the inappropriate paradigm of paternalism. Understanding how AI relates to doctors and influences doctor–patient communication is essential to promote more ethical medical practice. Both doctors' and patients' autonomy need to be considered in the light of AI.

23 January 2024 in BMC Medical Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LOLaura Arbelaez Ossa
Laura Arbelaez Ossa
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
SMStephen R. Milford
Stephen R. Milford
DSDavid Shaw
David Shaw
BEBernice S. Elger
Bernice S. Elger
MRMichael Rost
Michael Rost
Background: While the theoretical benefits and harms of Artificial Intelligence (AI) have been widely discussed in academic literature, empirical evidence remains elusive regarding the practical ethical challenges of developing AI for healthcare. Bridging the gap between theory and practice is an essential step in understanding how to ethically align AI for healthcare. Therefore, this research examines the concerns and challenges perceived by experts in developing ethical AI that addresses the healthcare context and needs. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 41 AI experts and analyzed the data using reflective thematic analysis. Results: We developed three themes that expressed the considerations perceived by experts as essential for ensuring AI aligns with ethical practices within healthcare. The first theme explores the ethical significance of introducing AI with a clear and purposeful objective. The second theme focuses on how experts are concerned about the tension that exists between economic incentives and the importance of prioritizing the interests of doctors and patients. The third theme illustrates the need to develop context-sensitive AI for healthcare that is informed by its underlying theoretical foundations. Conclusions: The three themes collectively emphasized that beyond being innovative, AI must genuinely benefit healthcare and its stakeholders, meaning AI also aligns with intricate and context-specific healthcare practices. Our findings signal that instead of narrow product-specific AI guidance, ethical AI development may need a systemic, proactive perspective that includes the ethical considerations (objectives, actors, and context) and focuses on healthcare applications. Ethically developing AI involves a complex interplay between AI, ethics, healthcare, and multiple stakeholders.

5 May 2025 in JMIR AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LOLaura Arbelaez Ossa
Laura Arbelaez Ossa
MRMichael Rost
Michael Rost
NBNathalie Bont
Nathalie Bont
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
DSDavid Shaw
David Shaw
BEBernice Simone Elger
Bernice Simone Elger
Background: The introduction of artificial intelligence (AI) into health care has sparked discussions about its potential impact. Patients, as key stakeholders, will be at the forefront of interacting with and being impacted by AI. Given the ethical importance of patient-centered health care, patients must navigate how they engage with AI. However, integrating AI into clinical practice brings potential challenges, particularly in shared decision-making and ensuring patients remain active participants in their care. Whether AI-supported interventions empower or undermine patient participation depends largely on how these technologies are envisioned and integrated into practice. Objective: This study explores how patients and medical AI professionals perceive the patient’s role and the factors shaping participation in AI-supported care. Methods: We conducted qualitative semistructured interviews with 21 patients and 21 medical AI professionals from different disciplinary backgrounds. Data were analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis. We identified 3 themes to describe how patients and professionals describe factors that shape participation in AI-supported care. Results: The first theme explored the vision of AI as an unavoidable and potentially harmful force of change in health care. The second theme highlights how patients perceive limitations in their capabilities that may prevent them from meaningfully participating in AI-supported care. The third theme describes patients’ adaptive responses, such as relying on experts or making value judgments leading to acceptance or rejection of AI-supported care. Conclusions: Both external and internal preconceptions influence how patients and medical AI professionals perceive patient participation. Patients often internalize AI’s complexity and inevitability as an obstacle to their active participation, leading them to feel they have little influence over its development. While some patients rely on doctors or see AI as something to accept or reject, these strategies risk placing them in a disempowering role as passive recipients of care. Without adequate education on their rights and possibilities, these responses may not be enough to position patients at the center of their care.

24 April 2022 in Clinical Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
DSDavid Martin Shaw
David Martin Shaw
LOLaura Arbelaez Ossa
Laura Arbelaez Ossa
BEBernice Simone Elger
Bernice Simone Elger
Informed consent is at the core of the clinical relationship. With the introduction of machine learning (ML) in healthcare, the role of informed consent is challenged. This paper addresses the issue of whether patients must be informed about medical ML applications and asked for consent. It aims to expose the discrepancy between ethical and practical considerations, while arguing that this polarization is a false dichotomy: in reality, ethics is applied to specific contexts and situations. Bridging this gap and considering the whole picture is essential for advancing the debate. In the light of the possible future developments of the situation and the technologies, as well as the benefits that informed consent for ML can bring to shared decision-making, the present analysis concludes that it is necessary to prepare the ground for a possible future requirement of informed consent for medical ML.

9 December 2022 in BMC Medical Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
DSDavid Shaw
David Shaw
BEBernice Simone Elger
Bernice Simone Elger
Healthcare cybersecurity is increasingly targeted by malicious hackers. This sector has many vulnerabilities and health data is very sensitive and valuable. Consequently, any damage caused by malicious intrusions is particularly alarming. The consequences of these attacks can be enormous and endanger patient care. Amongst the already-implemented cybersecurity measures and the ones that need to be further improved, this paper aims to demonstrate how penetration tests can greatly benefit healthcare cybersecurity. It is already proven that this approach has enforced cybersecurity in other sectors. However, it is not popular in healthcare since many prejudices still surround the hacking practice and there is a lack of education on hackers’ categories and their ethics. The present analysis aims to comprehend what hacker ethics is and who ethical hackers are. Currently, hacker ethics has the status of personal ethics; however, to employ penetration testers in healthcare, it is recommended to draft an official code of ethics, comprising principles, standards, expectations, and best practices. Additionally, it is important to distinguish between malicious hackers and ethical hackers. Amongst the latter, penetration testers are only a sub-category. Acknowledging the subtle differences between ethical hackers and penetration testers allows to better understand why and how the latter can offer their services to healthcare facilities.

19 August 2024 in JMIR AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
GLGiorgia Lorenzini
Giorgia Lorenzini
LOLaura Arbelaez Ossa
Laura Arbelaez Ossa
SMStephen Milford
Stephen Milford
BEBernice Simone Elger
Bernice Simone Elger
DSDavid Shaw
David Shaw
ECEva De Clercq
Eva De Clercq
Background: The discourse surrounding medical artificial intelligence (AI) often focuses on narratives that either hype the technology’s potential or predict dystopian futures. AI narratives have a significant influence on the direction of research, funding, and public opinion and thus shape the future of medicine. Objective: The paper aims to offer critical reflections on AI narratives, with a specific focus on medical AI, and to raise awareness as to how people working with medical AI talk about AI and discharge their “narrative responsibility.” Methods: Qualitative semistructured interviews were conducted with 41 participants from different disciplines who were exposed to medical AI in their profession. The research represents a secondary analysis of data using a thematic narrative approach. The analysis resulted in 2 main themes, each with 2 other subthemes. Results: Stories about the AI-physician interaction depicted either a competitive or collaborative relationship. Some participants argued that AI might replace physicians, as it performs better than physicians. However, others believed that physicians should not be replaced and that AI should rather assist and support physicians. The idea of excessive technological deferral and automation bias was discussed, highlighting the risk of “losing” decisional power. The possibility that AI could relieve physicians from burnout and allow them to spend more time with patients was also considered. Finally, a few participants reported an extremely optimistic account of medical AI, while the majority criticized this type of story. The latter lamented the existence of a “magical theory” of medical AI, identified with techno-solutionist positions. Conclusions: Most of the participants reported a nuanced view of technology, recognizing both its benefits and challenges and avoiding polarized narratives. However, some participants did contribute to the hype surrounding medical AI, comparing it to human capabilities and depicting it as superior. Overall, the majority agreed that medical AI should assist rather than replace clinicians. The study concludes that a balanced narrative (that focuses on the technology’s present capabilities and limitations) is necessary to fully realize the potential of medical AI while avoiding unrealistic expectations and hype.