Paleo-ecological niche modeling (paleoENM) estimates the niches and distributions of extinct species using fossil paleo-coordinates and local environmental data. While general circulation models (GCMs) have been used to estimate climate conditions in deep time, primarily for terrestrial vertebrates, variations in paleo-elevation models used in GCM construction can influence paleoENM outcomes. This study (1) examines the impact of the Cretaceous–Paleogene (K-Pg) mass extinction on the niche dimensions of the marine invertebrate group Turritellinae (Cerithoidea: Turritellidae) and (2) compares two paleo-elevation models’ effects on GCM-based species’ distribution predictions. Fossil occurrence data from the Maastrichtian and Danian periods were collected from the Paleobiology Database (PBDB), museum collections, and published literature. Environmental data were extracted from HadCM3L GCM simulations using Scotese- and Getech-based paleogeographic and p CO 2 boundary conditions. We estimated the niche dimensions of turritellines using maximum entropy (MaxEnt) and performed ordination analysis using kernel density estimation. MaxEnt model metrics showed that the Getech-based GCM outperformed the Scotese-based GCM. Geographic projections revealed minor differences in suitable habitat between the Maastrichtian and Danian in the Getech-based GCM, but overinflated predictions in the Scotese-based GCM. Niche overlap between the Maastrichtian and Danian was high, with both GCMs supporting niche similarity and equivalency. Our results suggest that differences in elevation model boundary conditions affected predicted distribution and niche patterns. This study offers a novel approach to understanding ecological persistence in invertebrates after mass extinction events, examines the robustness of GCM boundary conditions in paleoENM studies, and provides a framework for future paleoecological research on fossil invertebrates.
Paleontology provides insights into the history of the planet, from the origins of life billions of years ago to the biotic changes of the Recent. The scope of paleontological research is as vast as it is varied, and the field is constantly evolving. In an effort to identify “Big Questions” in paleontology, experts from around the world came together to build a list of priority questions the field can address in the years ahead. The 89 questions presented herein (grouped within 11 themes) represent contributions from nearly 200 international scientists. These questions touch on common themes including biodiversity drivers and patterns, integrating data types across spatiotemporal scales, applying paleontological data to contemporary biodiversity and climate issues, and effectively utilizing innovative methods and technology for new paleontological insights. In addition to these theoretical questions, discussions touch upon structural concerns within the field, advocating for an increased valuation of specimen-based research, protection of natural heritage sites, and the importance of collections infrastructure, along with a stronger emphasis on human diversity, equity, and inclusion. These questions offer a starting point—an initial nucleus of consensus that paleontologists can expand on—for engaging in discussions, securing funding, advocating for museums, and fostering continued growth in shared research directions.
The closure of the late Neogene interoceanic seaways between the Western Atlantic (WA) and Tropical Eastern Pacific (TEP)—commonly referred to as the Central American Seaway—significantly decreased nutrient supply in the WA compared to the TEP. In marine invertebrates, an increase in parental investment is expected to be selectively favored in nutrient‐poor marine environments as prolonged feeding in the plankton becomes less reliable. Here, we examine turritelline gastropods, which were abundant and diverse across this region during the Neogene and serve as important paleoenvironmental proxies, and test whether species exhibit decreased planktotrophy in the WA postclosure as compared to preclosure fossils and extant TEP species. We also test for differences in degree of planktotrophy in extant sister species pairs. Degree of planktotrophy was inferred by measuring the size of protoconchs, the species' larval shell that represents egg size. Protoconch size was compared between extant postclosure WA and TEP species and preclosure fossil species. To compare extant sister species, we reconstructed the phylogeny of available WA and TEP species using one nuclear (H3) and three mitochondrial markers (12S, 16S, and COI). Compared to the preclosure fossils, protoconch size increased in WA species but remained the same in the TEP species. In the two extant sister species pairs recovered in the phylogenetic analysis, the WA species are inferred to be nonplanktotrophic while the TEP species are planktotrophic. This suggests that decreased nutrient availability and primary productivity in the WA may have driven this change in developmental mode, and was the primary selective force resulting in postclosure turritelline extinctions.