14 November 2022 in Forest Ecology and Management
1 January 2022 in SSRN Electronic Journal
One of the most promising techniques for rapid detection of bark beetle-infested trees is the use of specially trained dogs. Due to the novelty of using dogs in detecting bark beetle-infested trees, prior evaluation or comparison with the traditional approaches is lacking. We used spruces briefly pre-treated with a synthetic pheromone at known tree positions in six experimental forest stands of 4–12 ha. The tree positions were selected based on their arrangement in a randomised scheme or in patches considered suitable for bark beetle colonisation. Three dogs of various ages, sex, and levels of experience in detecting Ips typographus were compared with three experienced human bark beetle specialists. We used GPS positioning of dog tracks (unleashed), handlers, and human experts and detection points during the search under a blind-test procedure for tracking positions. The potency of the search methods was estimated by a combination of three aspects: 1) search success: detection of infested trees, 2) search effort: time taken for detection and length of route, and 3) search efficiency: trees detected per unit time.Dog-handler pairs were overall more successful in detecting trees attacked by bark beetles than human experts. In particular, the success rate of dogs was higher in randomised plots. The human experts took twice the time to detect beetle infestations than dog-handler pairs for both types of tree position arrangements, while dog-handler pairs probably walked a longer route than human experts. The search efficiency of dogs was clearly higher than that of humans; the dog-handler search efficiency in randomised plots was four times higher than that of the human experts.Our results show that dogs were generally more effective in searching random plots, likely because they are known to find pheromones over long distances. The shorter time taken to detect a bark beetle-attacked tree early allows proactive management of larger endangered forest areas at the start of beetle flight. Using dog-handler pairs as searchers is crucial for active forest management at the beginning of an outbreak. The most efficient time for the use of dogs for detection would be during the spring flight period, when detection of first attacks and small hot spots could potentially prevent the development of larger infestations. The main advantage of using the dog search method is to amplify the time-window from about one week to one month from the detection to prompt removal of the infested trees from the forest.