Aronia (Aronia spp.) is a minor fruit species within the Rosaceae family that has gained increasing prominence in the food and health sectors in recent years, owing to its high antioxidant capacity. The genus is represented by three primary species: black chokeberry (Aronia melanocarpa), red chokeberry (Aronia arbutifolia), and their natural hybrid, purple chokeberry (Aronia prunifolia). In the present study, eight genotypes representing four commercial cultivars (‘Viking’, ‘Nero’, ‘Aron’, and ‘Galicjanka’) were evaluated for genetic stability under both in vivo and in vitro conditions using ISSR and iPBS molecular markers. To separate within-variety variability from between-variety variability, in vitro and in vivo samples of the same variety were combined into a single population (four populations in total; eight genotypes). ISSR primers generated monomorphic banding patterns and failed to detect polymorphism among the cultivars. In contrast, two of the five iPBS primers produced polymorphic profiles; the primers iPBS2400 and iPBS2378 exhibited polymorphism rates of 57.89% and 62.50%, respectively. These results demonstrate that both primers can detect genetic variation in the analyzed aronia genotypes. However, they differ in the total number of amplified bands and in the levels of polymorphism. For the iPBS2400 primer, the PIC, He, Ne, and Shannon’s diversity index (I) values were calculated as 0.426, 0.487, 1.772, and 0.614, respectively. For the iPBS2378 primer, the corresponding values were 0.431, 0.493, 1.809, and 0.617. The PIC values for these primers ranged from 0.426 to 0.431, while He values were between 0.487 and 0.493, and Shannon’s information index (I) values ranged from 0.614 to 0.617. Among the examined populations, the ‘Aron’ population showed the highest genetic diversity, whereas the ‘Viking’ population showed the lowest. The dendrogram generated using the Jaccard similarity coefficient indicated genetic distances ranging from 0.333 to 1.000. Overall, the findings demonstrate that ISSR markers exhibit limited discriminatory power, whereas iPBS markers are a more robust tool for detecting genetic variability among aronia cultivars. Additionally, the high degree of similarity between in vivo and in vitro samples supports the genetic stability of tissue culture-derived material.