Governments have been putting forward various proposals to stimulate and facilitate research on Artificial Intelligence (AI), develop new solutions, and adopt these technologies within their economy and society. Despite this enthusiasm, however, the adoption and deployment of AI technologies within public administrations face many barriers, limiting administrations from drawing on the benefits of these technologies. These barriers include the lack of quality data, ethical concerns, unawareness of what AI could mean, lack of expertise, legal limitations, the need for inter-organisational collaboration, and others. AI strategy documents describe plans and goals to overcome the barriers to introducing AI in societies. Drawing on an analysis of 26 AI national strategy documents in Europe analysed through the policy instrument lens, this study shows that there is a strong focus on initiatives to improve data-related aspects and collaboration with the private sector, and that there are limited initiatives to improve internal capacity or funding.
Time is now mature for researching AI implementation in the public sector, creating knowledge from real-life settings. The current paper goes in this direction, aiming to explore the challenges public organizations face in implementing AI. The research has been conducted through eight in-depth case studies of AI solutions. As a theoretical background, we relied on a framework proposed by Wirtz et al. [36] that identified four classes of challenges: AI Society, AI Ethics, AI Law and Regulations, and AI Technology Implementation. Our results first confirm the importance of the four classes of challenges. Second, they highlight the need to add a fifth class of challenges, i.e., AI Organizational change. In fact, public organizations are facing important challenges in settling AI solutions in daily operations, practices, tasks, etc. Finally, the five classes have been discussed, including more detailed insights extracted from the coding of the cases.
This study explores the challenges public organisations face when adopting and implementing artificial intelligence (AI) solutions, based on insights from eight European case studies. Building on and refining the foundational categorisation by Wirtz et al. (2019), our analysis positions “AI trustworthiness” as a core, cross-cutting challenge that interlinks societal acceptance, regulatory compliance, technological feasibility, and organisational practices. Furthermore, the study introduces “AI organisational and cultural change” as a distinct, previously underexplored category, highlighting the adjustments required in organisational structures and culture for successful AI integration. The findings also underscore differences between the challenges emerging during initial AI adoption phases and those surfacing once systems become operational. Finally, the study offers practical recommendations for policymakers and practitioners to effectively manage the complexities of AI integration in the public sector.