An ongoing mystery of HCI is how do well-intentioned designers consistently enable products with unintentionally evil consequences. Using “questionable values” as a lens, we retell and analyze four design scenarios for smart homes that were created by participants with an IoT toolkit we designed. The selected design scenarios reveal practices that violate principles of responsible smart home design. Through our analysis we show (1) how participants explore sensor-driven objectification of the home then leverage data for surveillance, nudging, and control over others; (2) how the dominant technosolutionist narratives of efficiency and productivity ground such questionable values; (3) and how the materiality of mass-produced sensors pre-mediates questionable design scenarios. We discuss how to attend to and utilize questionable values in design: Making space for questionable values will empower design researchers to better “look around corners”, anticipating tomorrow's concerns and forestalling the worst of their harms.
Soft toys foster strong and enduring early childhood attachments, with positive effects extending into adulthood. Smart toys are vulnerable to exploits and can harm users. Bridging this contrast, pairs of smart objects, equipped with only simple sensors and actuators, may support peripheral and emotional awareness. At the same time, how exactly such pairs should negotiate the soft/smart spectrum to yield positive long-term impacts for people connecting through them is a design challenge. We engage this with the Wheel of Plush co-design toolkit. It enables 8x8 different sensor-actuator combinations in plush for co-designers to explore multimodal interactions for smart soft toy pairs connected over distance. We detail our design process and offer insights on designing a toolkit that combines artisanal plush material with simple sensors and actuators. With the Wheel of Plush, we contribute a toolkit for exploring smart soft toy materiality, data-frugal multimodal interaction, and opportunities for smart soft toy pair co-design.
Behavioral data is ubiquitous in products, services, and systems that people interact with. It is increasingly used by design and HCI researchers and practitioners throughout their human-centered and participatory design processes. The highly dynamic nature of behavioral data makes it deeply intertwined with people, their behavior, and their experiences. Thus, it presents unique opportunities and challenges. This Special Interest Group will provide a space to reflect and discuss effective and responsible ways to engage with behavioral data in human-centered design processes. We will explore questions about the types and scale of data used, the contexts in which data is embedded and applied, the methods we rely on, and the forms of engagement of the multiple stakeholders. In doing so, our goal is to collaboratively develop a research agenda, setting the scope for an annual, international symposium on Data-Centric Design.
In this teachable moment we present our approach and tools for an ongoing teaching-learning project that brings the focus of human-data interaction in classical human-computer education, namely a human-centered design process. We explain our motivation, coming from an HCI course open not only for computer science students but for multiple disciplines aiming at integrating an interdisciplinary perspective. We motivate why we chose to focus on simple IoT sensor data and why a hands-on approach is useful for students. We discuss our Sensorkit, which is designed to support students in all relevant stages of the HCD process, from initial exploration, gaining insights and understanding, to prototyping, to evaluating a prototype that collects and visualizes sensor data in a small study with participants.
Annotation through additional graphic and textual elements is a helpful means of enriching visualizations. Previous work analyzing such annotations is primarily focused on infographics created by experts and tends to be generic for many different types of data and visualizations. In this work, we focus on the analysis of annotations of time-series data of simple sensors (e.g. light, temperature) from the smart home created by lay users. We take into account specifics of this context (type of data, home environment, limited expertise) and present the current status of our taxonomy that allows analyzing the WHY, WHAT, and HOW of such annotations. Our taxonomy is intended to analyze a large number of annotations created in smart home field studies. In the long-term this will inform implications for design to support lay users’ data interaction with smart home data in sensemaking as well as annotation and data management workflows.