20 May 2019 in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
Purpose: The selection of a suitable contractor for a project has a significant impact on project success. In order to avoid the selection of an incapable contractor, the capabilities of contractors must be assessed prior to tendering through pre-qualification. However, the pre-qualification process is characterized by partiality and ambiguity. In view of this, numerous models have been developed to solve the pre-qualification problems. Prior to the development of such models, it is very important to assess how the pre-qualification criteria impact project success criteria so as to aid in the selection of pre-qualification criteria while considering the project and client’s objectives. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to ascertain the relationship between contractors’ pre-qualification criteria and project success criteria. Design/methodology/approach: The study utilized explanatory research design in testing 35 hypotheses. The views of 121 practising quantity surveyors were solicited using a structured questionnaire and analyzed using the partial least square structural equation modeling to validate the hypothesis. Findings: In all, 13 of the 35 hypotheses were not supported. The findings indicated a clear relationship between contractors’ pre-qualification and project success. Practical implications: Therefore, it is evident that the practice of lowest evaluate bidder is not adequate for providing a satisfactory project outcome. It is, therefore, suggested that more emphasis should be placed on contractor’s technical abilities, health and safety and management capabilities as they have proven to have a significant correlation with the project success. Originality/value: This study provides insights to the how various pre-qualification criteria can impact the project success criteria and further contributes to the symbiotic that exist in the literature on pre-qualification and project success.
12 October 2015 in Architectural Engineering and Design Management
The significance of user involvement in design process towards generating value remains uncontested. It is however a challenge to identify the most appropriate strategy for engaging users to effectively participate in design process. This paper explores the suitability of the choosing by advantages (CBA) decision system for designers to engage users in design process. The paper specifically reports on a case application of CBA to make a typical design decision, such as the choice of a mode of operation of window openings, in the design of a three-storey lecture theatre at Takoradi Polytechnic in Takoradi, Ghana. A workshop, involving various stakeholders, including potential users of the project, was organized to apply CBA to choose among various modes of operation of window openings: louvres, sliding, awning, casement and pivoted. Findings, which were based on an active participation of a key member of the research team in the workshop, were further corroborated by direct observation and interview with some participants in the workshop. The findings point to CBA as a decision system capable of creating a collaborative forum for designers to engage users in design decisions.
4 December 2017 in Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology
Purpose: A major concern for construction professionals at the rural road agency in Ghana is the problem of fixing contract duration for bridge construction projects in rural areas. The purpose of the study was to develop a tool for construction professionals to forecast duration for bridge projects. Design/methodology/approach: In all, 100 questionnaires were distributed to professionals at the Department of Feeder Roads to ascertain their views on the work items in a bill of quantities (BOQ) that impact significantly on the duration of bridge construction projects. Historical data for 30 completed bridge projects were also collected from the same Department. The data collected were executed work items in BOQ and actual durations used in completing the works. The qualitative data were analysed using the relative importance index and the quantitative data, processed and analysed using both the stepwise regression method and artificial neural network (ANN) technique. Findings: The identified predictors, namely, in-situ concrete, weight of prefabricated steel components, gravel sub-base and haulage of aggregates, used as independent variables resulted in the development of a regression model with a mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of 25 per cent and an ANN model with a feed forward back propagation algorithm with an MAPE of 26 per cent at the validation stage. The study has shown that both regression and ANN models are appropriate for predicting the duration of a new bridge construction project. Research limitations/implications: The predictors used in the developed models are limited to work items in BOQs only of completed bridge construction projects as well as the small sample size. Practical implications: The study has developed a working tool for practitioners at the agency to forecast contract duration for bridge projects prior to its commencement. Originality value: The study has quantified the relationship between the work items in BOQs and the duration of bridge construction projects using the stepwise regression method and the ANN techniques.
1 January 2016 in Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice
One dimension of user-involvement in the design process is the management of user preferences. Managing user preferences, as a way towards optimizing value in the design process, could sometimes involve making tradeoffs among competing design options. The focus of this research is to explore the possibility of applying the choosing by advantages (CBA) decision system to manage user preferences in the design process, especially at the conceptual design stage. The CBA decision system was therefore applied to choose between two conceptual design options in relation to the expansion of an operating theater building at the Holy Family Hospital in Techiman, Ghana. A workshop involving the design team, user-group, and management of the hospital was organized to decide on the options using the CBA approach. The findings from this study illustrate the CBA decision aid as a transparent and participative decision system, capable of creating and sustaining a collaborative atmosphere of trust and respect in th...
31 July 2013 in Journal of Engineering, Project, and Production Management
GTGhana and Lecturer Accra Institute of Technology
Ghana and Lecturer Accra Institute of Technology
The process of cost modeling using risk analysis for construction projects is very crucial for the achievement of project success. The purpose of this paper is to present an analysis of the financial impact of risk factors affecting key construction work sections; using a systematic risk methodology based on empirical judgment. The failure mode effect analysis (FMEA) and the evidential reasoning methods are presented as qualitative and quantitative risk tools respectively. Data analysis from structured questionnaires revealed that four work sections are prone to high scope changes contemporaneous with seven risk factors. Contrary to the usual 10% contingency estimate allowed for construction projects in Ghana, an approximate overall physical contingency range of between 13.36% and 17.88% was determined using evidential reasoning methods. The likely impact of the integrated work sections and risk factors provide a clue to estimators on how to estimate and account for project cost contingency. The research concludes by recommending a framework for improving the estimation process of cost contingency through the integration of efficient risk management strategies, cost estimation and design management process.