28 January 2019 in Surface Topography: Metrology and Properties
Waviness is an important surface parameter in gears and the capability of measurement machines to capture this is largely unknown. The wavelengths of interest relate to transmission error (TE) and contact stress, both of which depend on a pair of gears and their geometry. TE directly relates to the noise and vibration during operation and contact stress drives failure of gear teeth. Accurately capturing the waviness wavelengths related to these parameters is consistent to geometric product specification (GPS) which requires: (i) specification of functional parameters (ii) description of how to measure each parameter and (iii) evaluation of parameter measurement uncertainty. A GPS compliant method is outlined with verification by two workpiece-like artefacts; one gear finished by surface grinding and one finished by a superfinishing process. The method evaluates a gear measurement machine (Klingelnberg P65) against a reference surface measurement instrument (Talysurf Intra 50). Results show that waviness measurement depends on measurement speed, probe choice, and strategy relating to different gear manufacturing methods. Actions to improve the characterisation method, such as including other key performance indicators and quantification of uncertainties, are suggested.
9 January 2023 in Measurement Science and Technology
Traditional gear measurement results are used to classify a gear tolerance grade in accordance with ISO 1328-1:2013 but as more stringent requirements are placed on gear performance it is important to also characterise performance related features properly on the gear flank surface. However, the measurement uncertainty of the measurement machines is not improving at the same rate as the tolerance requirements, and it is not uncommon to have less than 10 μm tolerances to be measured with a 1–3 μm measurement uncertainty capability. This breaks the ‘rule of thumb’ that the uncertainty should be smaller than one tenth of the value you are trying to measure. It is therefore important to review the measurement and evaluation process to identify if there are any areas for improvement within our current methods. Additionally, the measurements are being used to refine gear tooth contact analysis performance models and the development of optical and high speed tactile scanning measurement methods is allowing the full 3D gear flank surface measurement a feasible option on the shop floor. Greater understanding of the involute flank beyond the standard evaluation limits is thus required. These additional requirements have prompted this review of the effect that the Gaussian filters specified in ISO 1328-1:2013 have and that their characteristics are fully understood by those who must perform and interpret the measurement results. This paper examines the effect that these filters have on measurements where micro geometry corrections, such as tip relief, or tooth tip and end face chamfers are present. Methods of minimising these effects are reviewed with specific reference to strategies defined in ISO 16610-28:2016. Recommendations are offered to minimise the effects when evaluating the gear tolerance class and quantifying gear flank micro geometry.
5 January 2018 in Surface Topography: Metrology and Properties
Typically the quality of a gear pair is assessed based on simplified geometric tolerances which do not always correlate with functional performance. In order to identify and quantify functional performance based parameters, further development of the gear measurement approach is required. Methodology for interpolation of the full active helical gear flank surface, from sparse line measurements, is presented. The method seeks to identify the minimum number of line measurements required to sufficiently characterise an active gear flank. In the form ground gear example presented, a single helix and three profile line measurements was considered to be acceptable. The resulting surfaces can be used to simulate the meshing engagement of a gear pair and therefore provide insight into functional performance based parameters. Therefore the assessment of the quality can be based on the predicted performance in the context of an application.
29 December 2023 in Engineering Research Express
Gears are fundamental precision components that are crucial to many industries, including the wind energy sector. They are traditionally analysed using profile and helix line measurements but this does not consider the majority of the contacting surface with intricate surface variations that dictate functional performance. Practical measurement and evaluation of involute gear surfaces remain underexplored. This paper uses the Fourier and wavelet transforms to evaluate measured gear surface deviation harmonic content for a single trace, a trace set, and surface analysis and describes the utility of each. The methods are first demonstrated with synthetic data and then with measured data, then the measured data is simulated in a quasi-static FE tooth contact analysis, which yields insights not solely gleaned from harmonic analysis. The uncertainty of harmonic content analysis is to be established in future work and how that effects the uncertainty of simulated functional performance should be investigated.
1 March 2024 in Engineering Research Express
Gear users desire increased performance from their products and are interested in predicting the behavior (vibration, loss, service life, etc), and gear manufacturers are interested in adjusting machining parameters to manufacture even better gears. Both require proficient metrology. The evaluation standards were originally written to classify the manufacturing capability of machine tools and as tolerances tighten they may not provide enough insight into the functional performance of the manufactured parts. Furthermore, the advantage of modern coordinate and gear measuring machines is not fully taken into account when applying standardized measurement and evaluation strategies. Improved analysis tools can increase the relevant information gained from current measurement capabilities and enable more useful functional characteristics to be specified by designers and manufacturers. A key improvement is to move from profile and helix line traces to flank surfaces and corresponding fitted form elements. This is achieved by the introduced method. We present an inversion algorithm that fits dimension, form, and pose, and is applicable with current methods through freezing of specific fitting parameters. The method fits a synthetic point cloud with output results that are accurate to the 7th digit, or in practical terms are numerically equal. The inversion method can increase the understanding of error contributions and the functional performance of gears.
14 August 2024 in Measurement Science and Technology
Surface damage on involute gear tooth flanks can develop during the operation of a gearbox and affects their life, durability and efficiency. Understanding the extent and severity of this damage is critical, especially in long life applications such as wind turbines where gearboxes are a critical component that incur high down time and costs for replacement. Accessing gears in service is difficult and relating gear form measurements to the gear datum is often impossible without its removal. Additionally, damage measurements are typically not areal, which can miss the most severe areas, or require lengthy measurement times. This paper describes a method for characterising and quantifying localised damage relative to the undamaged tooth surface independent of the gear datum axis, and provides a method to estimate the damage location using involute co-ordinates. By taking soft replicas of the gear flank and measuring them with optical methods, the damage is characterised. This method allows for the areal evaluation of damage that relates to involute coordinates, which can be combined with nominal data or measurements after manufacture to create data sets for simulation in tooth contact analysis models, used to train condition monitoring models or for improved maintenance programming to improve reliability and reduce costly downtime.