Paradox theory generally suggests that paradox strategic cognition promotes willingness of established firms to invest in radical innovation development. However, literature neglects how paradox strategic cognition guides established firms to orchestrate resource facing resource tension. Integrating resource orchestration theory with paradox theory, we identified cannibalization and complementarity strategy as potential resource orchestration strategy for radical innovation development in established firms. The results indicate that paradox strategic cognition encourages the use of a complementarity strategy and discourages the use of a cannibalization strategy. Demand uncertainty also weakens the effect of paradox strategic cognition on resource leverage. We reveal the link between paradox strategic cognition and radical innovation by explaining how established firms choose between the two strategies. Moreover, our identification of the complementarity strategy enhances the literature on cannibalization and radical innovation.
27 August 2024 in The Journal of Technology Transfer
The iterative innovation literature recommends a basic prototype strategy because it reduces learning costs. Although customer cocreation during basic prototype iterations is assumed, the willingness of customers to engage in the iterative process remains unexamined. Basic prototypes may increase customers’ cost of engagement and thus reduce their motivation to cocreate new products with firms. Therefore, research on the effects of various prototype strategies on customer cocreation during iterative product development is needed. This study explores how basic and enhanced prototype strategies affect customer cocreation and new product development as well as the moderating effects of technological and demand uncertainties. Using survey data from 261 high-tech manufacturing firms, we examined the hypotheses with hierarchical regressions analysis, and find that although both the enhanced and basic prototype strategies promote customer cocreation, the effect of the enhanced strategy is stronger. Furthermore, to ensure customer cocreation, firms should adopt the basic prototype strategy under high levels of demand uncertainty and the enhanced prototype strategy under high levels of technological uncertainty. The results challenge the prevailing recommendation on basic prototype strategy by taking willingness of customers to participate into consideration. Different moderating effects of demand uncertainty and technological uncertainty also deepen the understanding on boundary condition of iterative process.
15 August 2024 in Industrial Management & Data Systems
Purpose: Although the literature provides insights into the role of experiential learning based on prototypes in identification of latent customer need, it offers different views on the role of product prototypes in improving the efficacy of learning customer need, and also neglects the role of vicarious learning in prototype-based experiential learning. In a data-rich environment, market big data create new opportunities to learn from vicarious, digitalized experiences that are not observable with prototype-based learning. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to compare the effects of product prototype strategies – basic prototype strategy and enhanced prototype strategy – on identification of latent customer needs, and determine how each prototype strategy interacts with vicarious learning based on market big data to identify latent customer needs.Design/methodology/approach: We collected data from 299 Chinese manufacturing firms via on-site surveys to explore our research question. All of our hypotheses were supported by the regression results.Findings: This study finds that both the enhanced and basic prototype strategies (experiential learning from direct market experience based on prototyping) have positive effects on latent need identification, but the effect of enhanced prototypes is stronger. Furthermore, the enhanced and basic prototype strategies have different interaction effects with market big data (vicarious learning from indirect market experiences) on latent need identification.Originality/value: This research extends the literature on prototype-based learning for latent need identification. It also contributes to the experiential prototype-based learning literature by exploring the role of vicarious learning based on market big data.
31 December 2024 in International Journal of Innovation Management