It has been argued that, throughout the Mesozoic, the immature growth forms of megaherbivorous dinosaurs competitively excluded small herbivorous dinosaur species, leading to the left-skewed species richness-body mass distributions of their fossil assemblages. By corollary, where large and small herbivores coexisted over a geologically significant period of time, they must have exhibited niche partitioning. We use multivariate ecomorphological analysis of the Late Cretaceous ornithischian dinosaur assemblage of North America to examine this prediction. Our results indicate good ecomorphological separation of most, but not all, species at small body size, although more work is required to demonstrate that these patterns were adaptive. Calculation of browse profiles using corrected abundance data and bracketed estimates of energy requirements suggests that immature megaherbivores – most particularly hadrosaurids – outstripped coexisting small ornithischian species in their control of the resource base.
Preserved records of tooth–bone interactions, known as tooth marks, can yield a wealth of information regarding organismal behavior and ecology. For this reason, workers in a wide range of disciplines, but particularly paleontology, have inspected and interpreted these features for decades. Although previous studies have gleaned invaluable insights, they have also described tooth marks using terminological frameworks that have been incompletely defined, have incorporated behavioral hypotheses in definitions, and/or have been inconsistently applied. To address these problems, we introduce the category-modifier (CM) system, the first system to both sort tooth marks into clearly defined main categories and use descriptive modifiers to characterize their appearance more precisely. The CM system is designed to apply to a wide range of vertebrates, to enable comparisons across disciplines and studies, and to help researchers keep their investigations into behavioral hypotheses free of circular reasoning.
8 October 2026 in Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology
Our ability to recognize larger-scale patterns in dinosaur feeding behaviour has been relativelylimited due to a general lack of large-scale, systematic surveys of isolated elements. This is especially truein the case of well-sampled formations such as the Dinosaur Park Formation of Dinosaur Provincial Park,Alberta. Studies involving tooth marks are one such area of research. To begin addressing these challenges,we present a survey of tooth-marked hadrosaurid vertebra collected predominately from Dinosaur ProvincialPark in southern Alberta, Canada. The majority (84.7%) of specimens bearing tooth marks are from thecaudal series. Changes in the average number of tooth marks per element, the position of tooth marks on thelateral surfaces of vertebrae, and inclined orientation of those tooth marks, suggest tooth mark distributionwas controlled by changes in flesh availability across the vertebral column. Similarities among the tooth marksdescribed in the present study and those documented in various case studies in the palaeontological literaturesuggest that feeding behaviour and tooth mark distribution is more strongly influenced by soft tissue distributionrather than taxonomic identity of the carnivore or carcass being fed upon. Our results also highlight theimportance of isolated specimens and the need for future large-scale studies involving multiple specimens inorder to capture overall carnivore feeding behaviour.
Paleopathologies and tooth marks observed on bones have long been used for behavioral interpretations of extinct organisms, including non-avian dinosaurs. However, our understanding of this behavior is limited by the rarity of large-scale surveys of recovered material. Here, we present a systematic survey of tooth marks across 148 hadrosaurid jugals from various Late Cretaceous formations of Alberta, Canada. Across 20 of the elements (13.6%), we observed 48 tooth marks, restricted to the lateral surface, 40% of which were located on the middle jugal body and showed no preferred orientation of the mark long axis. Across taphonomic modes, tooth marks are most common on isolated specimens, followed by bonebed specimens, with few articulated/semi-articulated/associated specimens showing marks. The proportion of tooth-marked to non-tooth-marked jugals is comparable to tooth-marking frequencies observed for modern mammalian carnivores. Although tooth marks were likely produced postmortem during feeding, it is unclear whether tooth marks were produced when the jugal was removed to access underlying adductor musculature or during the removal of extraoral tissues or a combination of these behaviors. Future large-scale surveys of hadrosaurid cranial elements could help clarify which of these explanations is more likely and elucidate Cretaceous carnivore carcass-processing behaviors. Our survey also identified an additional two specimens showing elongate healed marks extending anteroposteriorly across the lateral surface of the jugal body that are of unknown, but potentially the same, origin. Further specimens with similar paleopathologies could help decipher a likely mechanism of injury.