The citizenship jurisprudence of the European Court of Justice has raised hopes for a more social Europe and triggered fierce debates about ‘social tourism’. The article analyses how this case law is applied by EU member state administrations and argues that they are actively containing the Court’s influence. As a result, rather than reconciling the logics of ‘opening’ and ‘closure’, they are heading towards an uneasy coexistence between free movement and exclusive welfare states. The argument here is illustrated with empirical evidence from Austria and Germany. Although both countries have taken different approaches to EU migrants’ residency and social rights, they produce similar effects in practice: increasingly, EU migrants are being tolerated as residents with precarious status without access to minimum subsistence benefits. Ironically, attempts to restrict residency rights have resulted in a temporary extension of EU migrants’ access to welfare in some instances.
This paper traces the political debate about the export and the indexation of family benefits in the European Union (EU). We ask why such a technical legal issue has become salient in several EU member states. Explanations building on financial and political justifications prove to be insufficient. Rather, we argue, indexation has to be understood in the broader context of the contestation and constitutionalization of the free movement of workers. Free movement and equal treatment of workers have become contested with Eastern enlargement, but their legal framework is largely removed from political adjustments as it is constitutionalized in the Treaties and progressively interpreted by the Court of Justice (CJEU). At least symbolically, indexation promises to address these economic and legal challenges and serves as an “outlet” for member state governments. We illustrate our argument with empirical evidence from the debates preceding the Brexit referendum and the Austrian reform of family benefits.
2 August 2022 in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
Labour mobility within the European Union (EU) is still increasing, and often such workers carry out ‘essential’ work. Yet, while EU law accords certain labour and social rights, mobile workers de facto often have only limited rights. We study why especially these ‘essential’ workers are often exploited and focus on enforcement actors – control authorities checking upon and interest representation bodies pushing for workers’ rights. We thereby contribute to broader literature on the precarious character of EU free movement in practice. For one, we offer an analytical framework to grasp enforcement by using the dichotomy of police patrol and fire alarm, each breaking down for willingness and capabilities. For another, we stress the relevance of two factors hampering enforcement: While, as we argue, the demand for cheap labour by economies and societies of destination has an impact on the willingness to see rights guaranteed, the isolation of workers limits the capabilities of both police patrol and fire alarm. We illustrate our argument with empirical evidence from live-in care work and international road transport, mainly based upon semi-structured interviews with control authorities and interest representation bodies in Austria and Germany, and with additional interviews in Poland and Slovenia.
29 November 2021 in Journal of European Public Policy
The free movement of people (FMP) has been a core principle of European Union (EU) integration since its beginnings, but it has recently become contested. This article traces the politicization of FMP, and the topics associated with it, over time and across countries. Rather than constituting a linear or uniform trend, we argue that the politicization of FMP is differentiated: it is driven by particular events such as Eastern enlargement, mitigated by restrictive domestic policies anticipating the expansion of EU free movement rights, and that FMP is salient, but not polarized, from an emigration country perspective. Combining structural topic modelling and qualitative text analysis, we compare three decades of news coverage of FMP in Austria, Germany, Poland and the UK.
25 September 2024 in JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies
This article analyses the European Labour Authority (ELA) to understand the strategies EU agencies can use to improve EU rule implementation. Theoretically, we depart from established EU implementation and compliance research, broadly distinguishing between enforcement, information and socialization strategies. Empirically, the analysis draws on 18 semi‐structured background interviews with ELA and national officials and stakeholders as well as on documents from the negotiation of ELA's mandate, its first 5 years of operation and the review of the ELA regulation. We find that ELA tries to meet, at least partly, the high and diverse expectations of its stakeholders by pursuing a multitude of enforcement and information strategies in parallel. Given its limited resources to enforce and inform top‐down, however, most observers see the greatest potential for ELA in a socialization strategy, which prompts horizontal cross‐border co‐operation and builds trust amongst national enforcement authorities through joint inspections and liaison officers.
30 January 2020 in JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies
European integration, and especially the European Court of Justice, has challenged the national character of social rights; the latter have become increasingly transnational. This contribution examines the impact of the Court at the street level. It analyses how Member State administrations handle the social rights of mobile EU citizens in practice in case they are granted discretion. Therefore, a framework of shades of compliance is developed that captures Member State responses to EU law beyond the dichotomy of compliance and non‐compliance. I argue that Member State administrations tend to make the access to social benefits difficult. Still, there may be differences in the shade of compliance on the ground. Surprisingly, these differences cannot be explained by the party‐political environment but depend to a high degree on exposedness. The claim is empirically supported by a comparative study of Austrian welfare (and migration) administrations' practices.