14 May 2019 in Business Strategy and the Environment
6 March 2019 in Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management
31 August 2023 in Journal of Environmental Management
Over the last two decades, the non-financial disclosure requirement has become a major concern for companies, consumers, governments, and policymakers. While compelling evidence has accumulated over time on the positive effect that moving away from disclosing non-financial information within mandatory financial statements, conflicting findings have emerged on the relative merits that choice of non-financial reporting format, in particular between sustainability and integrated reporting, can have on analysts' forecast accuracy. In addition, recent evidence from a non-voluntary setting has suggested that such choice could influence the effect of ESG disclosure and consequently reduce information asymmetry. Aiming to shed some light on these propositions within a voluntary setting, we conducted an empirical study focusing on a representative sample of listed European companies. We retrieved and analysed the last ten years (2012-2021) of publicly available financial information about the top 600 companies listed in the Eurostoxx. Our findings indicate that both a sustainability and an integrated report are significantly associated with improved forecast accuracy, relative to an annual report. We also find that ESG disclosure is significantly moderated by such choice. The environmental pillar score was found to strongly and positively affect forecast error, independently from other controls including the social and governance pillars. For companies opting to disclose non-financial information within an annual report, alternative forms of communication will therefore become critical to ensure that financial analysts, and ultimately investors, are informed about the company's sustainability-related activities and plans. Future research should be directed at examining the magnitude and direction of these effects among small and medium-size listed companies and in other decision-making settings to test the generalisability of these findings.
26 August 2024 in Corporate Ownership and Control
Risk disclosure is an important issue discussed by the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) in its review process. We evaluate the effect that a risk SEC comment letter can have on US registrants’ disclosure and the consequent information value generated. We examine whether disclosure changes in Item 1A and Form 10-K occur due to the SEC review and affect forecast accuracy. We manually examine risk SEC comment letters and Forms 10-K from 405 US listed companies. We employ a difference-in-difference (DID) design and a multi-level, mixed-effect generalised linear model to quantify the SEC’s effect. We estimate a 9,88 per cent disclosure volume increase of Item 1A and a decrease of 2,77 per cent of the Form 10-K. Following the letter, forecast error decreases by 1 per cent but this change is not induced by the disclosure volume changes, confirming that risk disclosure may be too generic and boilerplate to provide a sufficiently strong signal for financial analysts.