According to the definition adopted in the European Union, novel foods are foods that were not consumed to a significant degree within the Union before May 15, 1997. This includes cultivated meat and insects. Novel foods are meant to play a critical role in the transition towards sustainable food systems. However, their success depends on whether and to what extent they will be incorporated into the diets at the population level. This review investigates consumers' perception of novel food products by narratively synthesising results on the influence of heuristics and biases triggered by emotions, personality traits, and socio-cultural factors. Empirical studies conducted in Western countries and published in English after 1997 were eligible, which led to 182 studies being included. Notably, most included studies focused on insects and cultivated meat. Disgust and fear are shown to be the main emotions driving rejection of novel foods, together with food neophobia and specific cultural norms common across countries included in the scope of the review. Familiarity with novel foods and curiosity both led to higher acceptance. Despite being investigated directly in a minority of studies, heuristics and related biases mostly fell under the "affect," the "natural-is-better," and the "trust" heuristics. The review also discusses to what extent consumers' perception reflects in the regulatory framework applicable to novel foods in the European Union, how it influences the regulation of insects and cultivated meat and which lessons can be drawn for the future of the regulatory framework.
In the European Union, the adequacy of the novel food framework to deal with cultivated meat has been questioned by several political initiatives at member state and Union levels. This contribution argues that the novel food framework is fit for regulating the entrance into the market of cultivated meat and that the use of the precautionary principle to ban cultivated meat production and commercialization is not justified. It then illustrates how existing regulatory provisions already provide the EU gastronomic heritage with adequate safeguarding, if and when cultivated meat will enter the EU market.
Cultivated meat, that is, animal flesh grown through cell culturing techniques, also termed cellular agriculture, is positioned by proponents, developers and some governments as the future of food and the solution to the multiple environmental issues associated with intensive animal agriculture. Governments around the world are starting to regulate cultivated meat. This article provides the first comparative analysis of how the United States, the European Union, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand are regulating cultivated meat. It finds that a broadly similar approach is emerging, yet there are significant differences regarding the degree of public participation, the level of consultation between the applicant and the regulator and the role of non‐scientific considerations such as environmental impacts and rural livelihoods. As part of this analysis, this article identifies and applies differing, normative interpretations regarding how cultivated meat should be regulated. These interpretative paradigms are in turn connected with diverging ideas about the role of technology and regulation in addressing environmental issues.
Purpose: This paper aims to discuss the innovation challenge in the alternative protein sectors of the European Union (EU) and Australia-New Zealand (AUSNZ) by comparing their respective novel food frameworks. The study investigates which regulatory provisions stakeholders perceive as barriers to innovation and proposes measures to address these obstacles. Design/methodology/approach: Alternative proteins are often legally classified as “novel foods” in both the EU and AUSNZ. A functional comparative legal analysis of the novel food frameworks of these two jurisdictions was conducted. Qualitative interviews with stakeholders active in the EU or AUSNZ alternative protein sectors complemented the legal analysis. The interviews aimed at gathering stakeholder perspectives on the framework within which they operate and discuss ways to foster innovation in their jurisdictions. Findings: While the AUSNZ framework is generally perceived as more innovation-friendly, particularly regarding breakthrough innovations like cultivated meat, the EU is viewed as a challenging regulatory environment. The duration of the authorisation procedure, differing levels of communication and opportunities for dialogue between stakeholders and regulators, along with the political stances of EU member states, emerged as the main elements to explain such differences. In both jurisdictions, a lack of support for small-scale companies was identified as a key factor hindering the innovation process. Originality/value: This study provides the first in-depth comparative analysis of the novel food frameworks in the EU and AUSNZ and explores stakeholder perceptions of their respective frameworks. Through this comparison, the study offers suggestions for enhancing both frameworks' ability to incentivise innovation in their alternative protein sectors.