This study compares the effectiveness of Collaborative Hybrid International Learning (CHIL) and Collaborative Online International Learning (COIL) in fostering global citizenship competencies through a reciprocal partnership between two private institutions, one in the United States and one in Ecuador. While COIL offers a cost-effective model for internationalizing the curriculum through virtual collaboration, CHIL extends the framework both conceptually and pedagogically by incorporating reciprocal, short-term in-person engagement rooted in equity-oriented and justice-driven internationalization. Using a mixed-methods quasi-experimental design, the research employed the Global Engagement Survey (GES), focus groups, and written reflections. Findings indicated that CHIL participants demonstrated greater gains in cultural humility, civic responsibility, and critical reflection compared to COIL participants. The study argues that CHIL represents a distinct theoretical evolution of COIL by positioning reciprocity, critical reflection, and North–South balance at the center of global learning.
The quality of relationships among students, faculty, and organizations is key to the impact of Service-Learning (SL) programs. However, research has primarily focused on student outcomes, leaving a gap in the analysis of these relationships and their commitment to social impact. This case study examines the relationships among stakeholders in an SL program at a private South American university through interviews with 30 participants. Given the lack of research on this topic in the region, the findings provide valuable insights for institutions implementing SL as a tool for social justice in education. The relationship between organizations and faculty was often found to be exploitative and superficial, though faculty expressed a willingness to improve it. In contrast, other interactions were more transformative, characterized by high levels of communication and engagement, reflecting progress toward a more critical and socially just approach. We conclude that ongoing evaluation is essential to improving stakeholder relationships in SL programs and establishing them as a tool for equity and social justice in higher education.