22 February 2024 in Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
Background: Social annotation has emerged as a promising educational technology that fosters collaborative reading and discussion of digital resources among learners. While the positive impact of social annotation on students' learning process and performance is widely acknowledged, students' behavioural patterns in social annotation are underexplored.Objectives: This study investigated patterns in students' use of annotation and response behaviours in social annotation activities. We also explored how students' performance in the behavioural, cognitive, emotional, and social dimensions varied based on their behavioural patterns.Methods: We recruited 93 undergraduates who were enrolled in an elective course at a large North American University. Students were tasked with collaboratively annotating the class readings uploaded to Perusall, a social annotation platform, over 7 weeks. We used metaclustering to determine the optimal number of clusters pertaining to student behaviours. We compared the differences among clusters across multiple performance dimensions.Results and Conclusions: Two distinct clusters were identified and defined as initiators and responders. We found that responders had significantly longer active reading time and exhibited greater social annotation effort compared to initiators. However, initiators received more peer acknowledgement, as evidenced by higher upvotes. No significant difference was found in cognitive insight between initiators and responders, but responders demonstrated significantly higher cognitive discrepancy. Additionally, there were no significant differences in positive and negative tones between initiators and responders; however, responders displayed higher levels of prosocial behaviours than initiators. This study has significant practical implications regarding promoting students' collaborative learning experience in social annotation.
26 September 2023 in EdArXiv
The significance of interdisciplinary learning has been well recognized in higher education institutions. However, when teaching interdisciplinary learning to junior undergraduate students, their limited disciplinary knowledge can hinder their learning performance. The extensive information of ChatGPT and its ability to engage in human-like conversations hold promise in enriching undergraduate students with the disciplinary knowledge they lack. In this exploratory study, we engaged 130 undergraduate students to examine how ChatGPT influences their demonstrated interdisciplinary quality and perceived interdisciplinary problem-solving with a three-condition quasi-experiment. Our results show that students under the ChatGPT condition demonstrated improved disciplinary grounding, suggesting ChatGPT’s ability to enhance students’ disciplinary knowledge. However, under all conditions, students showed weak performance in knowledge integration, indicating ChatGPT’s limited use in facilitating certain aspects of interdisciplinary learning. These findings underscore the significance of fostering students' integration skills and highlight the need for further research to explore the specific conditions and aspects in which ChatGPT can contribute to learning.