Participatory research, in which people with lived experience of the study phenomenon are involved as collaborators, has been conducted for decades; however, these innovations have struggled to take hold in mental health settings—until recently. The slow uptake of community partnered research in mental health has been unfortunate, especially because this field already suffers from poor community relations, pervasive community mistrust, and racial and ethnic disparities. But now, people with lived experience of severe mental illness—long considered to be “incapable” of functioning as co-researchers—are beginning to be included on research teams. However, training and opportunities for conducting such work are still lacking. This report describes a two-year initiative to improve the quality and quantity of participatory research being conducted in a department of psychiatry at a large medical school, which culminated in an innovative training program for both researchers and patients, developed in direct collaboration with stakeholders. In addition to detailing this program, we also discuss the deep legacy of mental health mistrust and our own efforts to address issues of social justice and health equity.
There are increased efforts to improve patient-provider relations and engagement within North American mental health systems. However, it is unclear how these innovations impact care for ethnic minorities, a group that continues to face social and health disparities. This study examined one such engagement innovation-person-centered care planning-to gain a better understanding of this overall process. We specifically explored how mental health providers trained in person-centered care planning work with their patients of Latinx and Asian backgrounds. In-depth interviews were conducted with mental health providers in community clinics, and narratives were analyzed via phenomenological methods. Findings revealed that regardless of specific practice innovations, it was providers' own embeddedness in their mental health organizational culture that became conspicuous as a determinant of care. This culture contained implicit preferences for clients considered to be ideal (e.g., are verbal, admit a problem or illness, accept services, and are individually oriented). These clients were experienced as ideal largely because they helped the system operate efficiently. Findings suggest that these organizational norms, preferences, and expectations-and bureaucratic demands for efficiency-may engender an implicit organizational bias that creates barriers for culturally different groups. These biases may also hinder practice innovations, whether patient-centered, disparities-focused, or otherwise. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).
18 May 2023 in Journal of Substance Use and Addiction Treatment
This chapter argues that continued use of inherited models of case management limits the progress that otherwise could be made in actualizing this shift from a deficit- and institution-based framework to a recovery and community integration paradigm. This paradigm calls for new models of community-based practice that move beyond the management of cases and beyond merely semantic changes that introduce new terms for old practices. One such model that appears to be emerging in the field is that of tour guide, community guide, or, “recovery guide.” Prior to introducing this model, the chapter first reviews existing models of case management that have underlain the last 40 years of community-based practice. It then outlines the principles of care that ground a recovery-oriented alternative; describes the key components of the recovery guide model; and considers some of the broader implications of this model for community-based practice.