Joan E. Broderick

Joan E. Broderick

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Joan E. Broderick

Dornsife Center for Self-Report Science, United States

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

50Years (1977-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 April 2003 in Controlled Clinical Trials
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASArthur A Stone
Arthur A Stone
SSSaul Shiffman
Saul Shiffman
JSJoseph E Schwartz
Joseph E Schwartz
JBJoan E Broderick
Joan E Broderick
MHMichael R Hufford
Michael R Hufford

18 May 2002 in BMJ
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
ASArthur A Stone
Arthur A Stone
SSSaul Shiffman
Saul Shiffman
JSJoseph E Schwartz
Joseph E Schwartz
JBJoan E Broderick
Joan E Broderick
MHMichael R Hufford
Michael R Hufford

1 March 2003 in Psychosomatic Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BKBrigitte M. Kudielka
Brigitte M. Kudielka
JBJoan E. Broderick
Joan E. Broderick
CKClemens Kirschbaum
Clemens Kirschbaum
Ambulatory saliva collections for subsequent analysis of free cortisol levels are now frequently applied to measure adrenocortical activity in healthy subjects and patient populations. Despite the prime importance of accurate timing of saliva collection outside the laboratory, no data are available on the compliance of study participants following a given sampling protocol. This study investigated how accurately subjects adhered to the instructions to collect six saliva samples throughout 1 day. Subjects were instructed to collect six saliva samples throughout 1 day (directly after awakening, 30 minutes after awakening, 11 AM, 3 PM, 8 PM, 10 PM). Objective compliance was measured using an electronic monitoring device given to the subjects either with (“informed”N = 23) or without (“noninformed”N = 24) their knowledge of the nature of the device. Data on subjective compliance were obtained by self-report. Thirty-one subjects (74%) were found to comply with the sampling instructions, and 11 (26%) failed at least once to obtain the saliva sample at the correct time of day. Nine of the 11 noncompliant subjects (82%) had two or more noncompliant samples. Fifty-five percent (6 of 11) of the noncompliant subjects took sample 2 outside the sampling window. The circadian cortisol profile differed significantly between compliant and noncompliant subjects (F = 7.98, p = .007). The most important effect of compliance was seen in the rise of cortisol at awakening. Compliant subjects showed a robust increase, whereas noncompliant individuals had only minimal changes from baseline at 30 minutes after awakening (t = 2.89, p = .007). Thus the steepness of the circadian cortisol decline was greater for compliant subjects (t = 2.10, p = .043). Furthermore, the informed group adhered more closely to the sampling protocol than the noninformed subjects (p = .001). Self-reported compliance also differed significantly between study groups (p = .03). In the noninformed group, self-reported sampling accuracy was significantly higher than objectively measured compliance (p = .03); the two measures were similar in the informed group (p = NS). A significant number of subjects did not obtain saliva samples reliably in an ambulatory setting. This can partially invalidate the cortisol results and mask potential differences between subject groups of interest. We therefore recommend the use of electronic monitoring devices or other suitable methods and that study participants be informed about the device when ambulatory saliva collection is performed.

30 September 2008 in Pain
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JBJoan E. Broderick
Joan E. Broderick
JSJoseph E Schwartz
Joseph E Schwartz
GVGregory Vikingstad
Gregory Vikingstad
MPMichelle Pribbernow
Michelle Pribbernow
SGSteven Grossman
Steven Grossman
ASArthur A. Stone
Arthur A. Stone
The length of the reporting period specified for items assessing pain and fatigue varies among instruments. How the length of recall impacts the accuracy of symptom reporting is largely unknown. This study investigated the accuracy of ratings for reporting periods ranging from 1 day to 28 days for several items from widely used pain and fatigue measures (SF36v2, Brief Pain Inventory, McGill Pain Questionnaire, Brief Fatigue Inventory). Patients from a community rheumatology practice (N=83) completed momentary pain and fatigue items on average of 5.4 times per day for a month using an electronic diary. Averaged momentary ratings formed the basis for comparison with recall ratings interspersed throughout the month referencing 1-day, 3-day, 7-day, and 28-day periods. As found in previous research, recall ratings were consistently inflated relative to averaged momentary ratings. Across most items, 1-day recall corresponded well to the averaged momentary assessments for the day. Several, but not all, items demonstrated substantial correlations across the different reporting periods. An additional 7 day-by-day recall task suggested that patients have increasing difficulty actually remembering symptom levels beyond the past several days. These data were collected while patients were receiving usual care and may not generalize to conditions where new interventions are being introduced and outcomes evaluated. Reporting periods can influence the accuracy of retrospective symptom reports and should be a consideration in study design.

1 July 2003 in Pain
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASArthur A. Stone
Arthur A. Stone
JBJoan E. Broderick
Joan E. Broderick
JSJoseph E Schwartz
Joseph E Schwartz
SSSaul Shiffman
Saul Shiffman
LLLeighann Litcher-Kelly
Leighann Litcher-Kelly
PCPamela Calvanese
Pamela Calvanese
Patient self-reports are the primary method for capturing the experience of pain, and diaries are often used to collect patient self-reports. This study was designed to determine if momentary monitoring of pain with an electronic diary affected pain levels over time, if it affected weekly recall of pain, and if daily sampling density affected compliance rates and patients' reactions to the study. Ninety-one patients with chronic pain were randomized into four groups with differing levels of momentary monitoring over 2 weeks. Little support was found for reactivity defined as temporal shifts in pain over the study or as changes in recalled weekly pain due to momentary monitoring. Compliance with the electronic diary protocol was 94% or better, and was not related to sampling density. Patients reported little difficulty with the diary procedures and were not unduly burdened by the protocol.

1 July 2012 in Obesity
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
ASArthur A. Stone
Arthur A. Stone
JBJoan E. Broderick
Joan E. Broderick