In recent decades, the contested practice of charitable food aid has become a symbol of persisting poverty and failing welfare states to provide adequate social safety nets. While European countries face disappointing poverty levels and a declining poverty-reducing capacity of social transfers, the number of people relying on third-sector food aid initiatives is growing. Yet, the empirical understanding of the relevance and financial importance of food aid for low-income households, and its relation to rights-based social protection, is limited. This dissertation aims to broaden the insights on the dynamics between charity-based and rights-based anti-poverty strategies by analysing the scope and complex position of food aid in European welfare states. It bundles four research articles that build on social policy literature and the concepts of social rights and the welfare mix. Applying a mixed-methods approach and combining newly collected with existing data, I examine the budgets and financial relevance of food aid, its underlying rationales and the involvement of different actors shaping charitable food aid. An innovative data collection in food charities across four EU countries shows that the financial relevance of food aid is not marginal for households on minimum income benefits. This is made possible due to the high reliance on unpaid volunteers, donated food surpluses and financial support to third-sector food charities. Subsidies from various government levels, particularly the EU through the Fund for European Aid to the Most Deprived (FEAD), play a crucial role. Nevertheless, my findings call for a more needs-based distribution of EU social funding towards the Member States with the greatest social needs. Furthermore, while the set-up of charity-based food aid seems financially efficient, the application of in-kind transfer valuation methods reveals that food parcels are not fully in line with recipients’ preferences and needs, thereby reducing its poverty mitigating effect. Moreover, the distribution of food parcels appears to be a fragmented and uncertain form of support with discretionary and stigmatizing characteristics. Still, the case study research in several EU welfare states shows that local governments are collaborating with and proactively referring people to third-sector food aid organisations, using it to top up deficient rights-based social protection. Overall, the major rationales (poverty mitigation, and ecological and paternalistic motives) for upholding the practice of charitable food aid indicate substantial power imbalances in favour of governments and the private sector, and to the detriment of vulnerable end beneficiaries.