24 September 2024 in International Journal of Islamic Education, Research and Multiculturalism (IJIERM)
In carrying out their duties as Substitute Notaries, the obligation to adhere to the law is imperative as stipulated in the legislation, serving as a foundation for fulfilling their responsibilities. According to Article 65 of Law No. 2 of 2014 on the Position of Notary, it is stated that a Notary, Substitute Notary, and Temporary Notary Officer are accountable for every deed they draw up, even after the Notarial Protocol has been handed over or transferred to the custodian of the Notarial Protocol. Therefore, a Substitute Notary must be legally responsible for the deeds they prepare in judicial processes. This is because the deeds created by a Substitute Notary are authentic deeds made by an authorized official and hold evidentiary power in court. In performing their duties as Substitute Notaries in drawing up authentic deeds, there is a possibility of legal issues arising concerning the deeds they create, which may result in the Substitute Notary becoming entangled in legal problems. The Notary Honorary Council (Majelis Kehormatan Notaris) is an institution that exercises authority in providing guidance to Notaries and has the duty to grant approval for Notaries in judicial processes. The obligation to obtain approval from the Notary Honorary Council for Notaries is a form of legal protection for Notaries, as outlined in Article 66 paragraph 1 of the Notary Law. This legal protection is aimed at maintaining the dignity of the Notary profession and safeguarding the interests of the parties involved in legal acts within the deeds. The urgency in this matter lies in Article 66 paragraph 1 of the Notary Law, where the Notary Honorary Council has the authority to grant approval to Investigators, Public Prosecutors, and Judges to conduct examinations and obtain the original deed (Minuta) from the Notary, due to the Notary's obligation to keep the deeds they draw up confidential. To address this issue, a research method is necessary, and the method employed in this research is the Normative Juridical method, which refers to a scientific research method used to find the truth based on the legal logic from a normative perspective.The conclusion drawn from this research is that there is a legal vacuum concerning the regulation of Article 66 paragraph 1 with respect to Substitute Notaries in civil judicial processes.
28 January 2020 in Fiat Justisia: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum
ASEAN had created the ASEAN Regional Guidelines on Competition Policy and Handbook on Competition Policy and Law in ASEAN for Business as guides for assessment of the behaviour of business people in the industry and market. The Regional Guidelines “only” help member countries in increasing awareness of the importance of business competition policies. The execution of business competition is then left to the ASEAN member country, to be in accordance with national business competition policies. Meanwhile, the ASEAN Economic Community will allow business people in ASEAN countries to conduct business transactions in whichever country they prefer. Without clear regulations, businesspeople can freely carry out cross-border transactions that can disrupt the domestic market of each ASEAN member country. Differences in regulatory substances and the absence of competition law regulations in several ASEAN member countries will undoubtedly become a challenge for the application of competition laws by businesspeople in the ASEAN regional market. However, in relation to AFTA, the primary urgency is instead the realization of imposing tariffs of 0-5% by performing the harmonization of regulations in the field of Customs and the removal of other forms of Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs). The removal of trade barriers is one of the things that are also regulated in competition law. This article is the result of normative juridical research that analyzes the differences in the substance of competition law in several ASEAN countries along with their juridical implications, to be able to evaluate the urgency of harmonizing legal regulations on business competition among the member countries of ASEAN.
26 April 2024 in Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan
This article analyzes the readiness of Indonesian competition law regarding the utilization of big data and reinforcement learning as tools to improve retailers' pricing strategies, ultimately leading to increased profitability and higher customer engagement and loyalty. It conducts a comprehensive review of scholarly literature pertaining to adaptive algorithmic pricing, with a specific focus on analyzing trends and the impacts of algorithmic pricing strategies. The literature review spans the years 2018 to 2022 and adheres to PRISMA criteria, with academic journals from Scopus serving as the primary source of research papers. The findings of this review indicate that it is evident that the most frequently utilized type of algorithm is RL, that shares a resemblance to human learning processes. Competition law enforcement should consider the possibility of illicit agreements between these artificial agents of colluding companies. In light of the capacity of EAs to facilitate the coordination of illicit agreement, it is imperative to consider the reformulation of Article 5 of Law Number 5 of 1999 and Regulation of KPPU Number 4 of 2011, particularly regarding the classification of price-fixing, to be adjusted to the latest developments, particularly regarding "EAs". ITE Law also should not be limited to EAs merely acting as “tools”. Instead, it should acknowledge their capacity to function as “AI Agents” capable of autonomous action.
30 October 2024 in Notaire
Novation is one method of breaking an agreement. Novation is not effectively governed in Article 1413 of the Civil Code, the Banking Law, or the Mortgage Law. Therefore, it is frequently observed in practice that novations are carried out unilaterally by creditors and without the original debtor’s involvement (passive subjective novation). When the Novation is implemented for the Credit Agreement and is also weighed down by Mortgage Rights, issues arise. The legal relationship between the Creditor and the original Debtor will be terminated when the Debtor is renewed. Between new Debtors and existing Creditors, Novation creates a new legal relationship. Only if there has been an engagement between himself and the original Debtor would the new Debtor have the right to the guarantee of Mortgage. Novation can be one of the exit strategies for avoiding the possibility of bad loans, but particularly for Credit Agreements that are Mortgage-burdened, it is necessary to use the principle of prudence, which includes the urgency of having a companion deed as well as other administrative procedures, so that the existence of Mortgage can still be a “safety measure” for the agreement for the renewed credit.Keywords: Novation; Bank Credit Agreement; Land Mortgage; Notary. AbstrakSalah satu cara mengakhiri perikatan adalah Novasi. Di dalam Pasal 1413 KUHPerdata, Undang-Undang Perbankan dan Undang-Undang Hak Tanggungan, Novasi tidak diatur secara. Oleh karena itu, di dalam praktek banyak ditemui Novasi dilakukan secara sepihak oleh Kreditur dan tanpa melibatkan Debitur lama (Novasi Subyektif Pasif). Permasalahan muncul ketika Novasi tersebut dilakukan untuk Perjanjian Kredit dibebani pula Hak Tanggungan. Bahwa adanya pembaharuan Debitur, maka hubungan hukum antara Kreditur dengan Debitur lama menjadi terhapus. Novasi menghadirkan hubungan hukum baru antara Kreditur dengan Debitur baru. Dalam kaitannya dengan jaminan Hak Tanggungan, maka Debitur baru hanya akan mempunyai hak, jikalau telah terjadi perikatan antara dirinya dengan Debitur lama. Novasi dapat menjadi salah satu exit strategy dalam mengatasi kemungkinan kredit macet, namun khususnya untuk Perjanjian Kredit yang dibebani Hak Tanggungan, perlu asas kehati-hatian termasuk urgensi adanya akta pendamping dan juga proses administrasi lainnya sehingga keberadaan Hak Tanggungan tetap dapat menjadi “pengaman” atas perjanjian kredit yang diperbaharui tersebut.Kata Kunci: Novasi; Perjanjian Kredit Perbankan; Hak Tanggungan Atas Tanah; Notaris.
29 August 2025 in Legal horizons
This research examines the legal protection for consumers who buy apartment units through pre-project selling schemes using underhand Sales and Purchase Agreement (PPJB). Although considered efficient by the developer, this practice puts consumers in a vulnerable position due to the absence of formal legal protection and without the involvement of a notary. This research uses a normative juridical approach to examine the lack of explicit sanctions in Article 43 of Law No. 20/2011 on Flats, which is often used by developers to avoid obligations. The findings show an imbalance in the legal power structure between consumers and developers, exacerbated by weak supervision and legal loopholes. PPJB, which should be made before a notary, is often used as an informal contract that does not provide effective protection for consumers. This research concludes that urgent regulatory reform is needed to require notarization of PPJBs and clarify administrative and civil sanctions for violations. The novelty of this research lies in the focus on the imbalance of legal power in PPS transactions and the proposal of prescriptive norms that ensure contractual justice for consumers.
8 April 2025 in Law and Safety
This paper discusses the legal position of flat developers who have two or more creditors and are unable to fulfill their obligations to pay debts that are due. Under the provisions in the Bankruptcy Law, a debtor who is unable to pay its debts that have matured may be declared bankrupt by a court decision, provided that the requirements outlined in Article 8 paragraph (4) are fulfilled, namely, that the debt is directly provable. If the debt can be simply proven, the court is obliged to grant the bankruptcy application. However, the Supreme Court has adopted a policy in the form of a circular providing guidance. In particular, Supreme Court Circular No. 3 of 2023, in subparagraph (2) of paragraph 2 of letter B, states that bankruptcy or suspension of debt payment applications against unqualified developers cannot be categorised as cases supported by mere evidence. This research employs normative legal methods using a statute-based approach. The findings of the study indicate that a Supreme Court circular has a lower hierarchical position than a law, and its legal force depends on its compliance with the law. Therefore, if a circular is found to be contrary to higher law, it may be invalidated and any decision based solely on such a circular may be appealed. In practice, developers or debtors who fail to meet their obligations to creditors will have their assets treated as bankruptcy estate, distributed based on the principle of equal treatment among creditors. Ultimately, this paper concludes that bankruptcy law remains the most efficient legal solution due to the simple mechanism of proof it offers, and that the Supreme Court circular letter has no authority to override the law as established by statutory law.