During persistent antigen stimulation, such as in chronic infections and cancer, CD8 T cells differentiate into a hypofunctional programmed death protein 1–positive (PD-1 + ) exhausted state. Exhausted CD8 T cell responses are maintained by precursors (Tpex) that express the transcription factor T cell factor 1 (TCF-1) and high levels of the costimulatory molecule CD28. Here, we demonstrate that sustained CD28 costimulation is required for maintenance of antiviral T cells during chronic infection. Low-level CD28 engagement preserved mitochondrial fitness and self-renewal of Tpex, whereas stronger CD28 signaling enhanced glycolysis and promoted Tpex differentiation into TCF-1 neg exhausted CD8 T cells (Tex). Furthermore, enhanced differentiation by CD28 engagement did not reduce the Tpex pool. Together, these findings demonstrate that continuous CD28 engagement is needed to sustain PD-1 + CD8 T cells and suggest that increasing CD28 signaling promotes Tpex differentiation into more functional effector-like Tex, possibly without compromising long-term responses.
Summary: During persistent antigen stimulation, PD-1 + CD8 T cells are maintained by progenitor exhausted PD-1 + TCF-1 + CD8 T cells (Tpex). Tpex respond to PD-1 blockade, and regulation of Tpex differentiation into more functional Tex is of major interest for cancer immunotherapies. Tpex express high levels of Inducible Costimulator (ICOS), but the role of ICOS for PD-1 + CD8 T cell responses has not been addressed. In chronic infection, ICOS-deficiency increased both number and quality of virus-specific CD8 T cells, with accumulation of effector-like Tex due to enhanced survival. Mechanistically, loss of ICOS signaling potentiated FoxO1 activity and memory-like features of Tpex. In mice with established chronic infection, ICOS-Ligand blockade resulted in expansion of effector-like Tex and reduction in viral load. In a mouse model of hepatocellular carcinoma, ICOS inhibition improved cytokine production by tumor-specific PD-1 + CD8 T cells and delayed tumor growth. Overall, we show that ICOS limits CD8 T cell responses during chronic antigen exposure.
Immunotherapy transformed cancer treatment, yet precise correlates of response remain to be defined. While intratumoral follicular helper like (Tfhl) CD4 T cells and IgG1 + B cells have been associated with improved outcomes to PD-1 blockade for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), their mechanisms contributing to response are unclear. To address this question, we developed a murine model of HCC and examined CD8, CD4 and B cell responses. Increasing CD4-help sensitizes mice to PD-1 blockade, in a CD4- and CD8-dependent manner. Tumor-specific CD4 T cells contained Tfhl and Th1 populations, and both Bcl6 and T-bet were required for efficacy. Antigen-specific B cells were essential for CD4-helper expansion, yet secretion of antibodies was not required for long-term survival. Thus, B cells are critical for effective immunotherapy, but secreted antibodies are not.