Natalie Fischer

Natalie Fischer

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Natalie Fischer

CogNosco Lab, Department of Psychology and Cognitive Science, University of Trento, Rovereto, Trento, Italy

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

2Years (2025-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
20 January 2026 in Journal of Computational Social Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Edith HaimEdith Haim
Edith Haim
NFNatalie Fischer
Natalie Fischer
SCSalvatore Citraro
Salvatore Citraro
Giulio RossettiGiulio Rossetti
Giulio Rossetti
Massimo StellaMassimo Stella
Massimo Stella
Creativity is a fundamental skill of human cognition. We use textual forma mentis networks (TFMN) to extract network (semantic/syntactic associations) and emotional features from approximately one thousand human-, GPT3.5-, and Sonnet 3.7-generated stories. Using Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) we test whether features relative to Mednick’s associative theory of creativity can explain creativity ratings assigned by humans or AI raters. Using XGBoost, we examine 5 scenarios: (i) human rating human stories, (ii) GPT-3.5 rating human stories, (iii) GPT-3.5 rating GPT-3.5 stories, (iv) Sonnet 3.7 rating human stories, and (v) Sonnet 3.7 rating Sonnet 3.7 stories. Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 ratings differ significantly from human ratings not only in terms of correlations but also because of feature patterns identified with XAI methods. GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 favour “their own” stories and rate human stories differently from humans. Feature importance analysis with SHAP scores shows that: (i) network features are more predictive for human creativity ratings but also for ratings by GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 for human stories; (ii) emotional features played a greater role than semantic/syntactic network structure in GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 rating their own stories. These quantitative results underscore key limitations in the ability of GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 to align with human assessments of creativity. We emphasise the need for caution when using AI models to assess and generate creative content, as they may not yet capture the nuanced complexity that characterises human creativity.

2 September 2025 in PsyArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
Edith HaimEdith Haim
Edith Haim
NFNatalie Fischer
Natalie Fischer
SCSalvatore Citraro
Salvatore Citraro
Giulio RossettiGiulio Rossetti
Giulio Rossetti
Massimo StellaMassimo Stella
Massimo Stella
Creativity is a fundamental skill of human cognition. We use textual forma mentis networks (TFMN) to extract network (semantic/syntactic associations) and emotional features from approximately one thousand human-, GPT3.5-, and Sonnet 3.7-generated stories. Using Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) we test whether features relative to Mednick’s associative theory of creativity can explain creativity ratings assigned by humans or AI raters. Using XGBoost, we examine 5 scenarios: (i) human rating human stories, (ii) GPT-3.5 rating human stories, (iii) GPT-3.5 rating GPT-3.5 stories, (iv) Sonnet 3.7 rating human stories, and (v) Sonnet 3.7 rating Sonnet 3.7 stories. Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 ratings differ significantly from human ratings not only in terms of correlations but also because of feature patterns identified with XAI methods. GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 favour “their own” stories and rate human stories differently from humans. Feature importance analysis with SHAP scores shows that: (i) network features are more predictive for human creativity ratings but also for ratings by GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 for human stories; (ii) emotional features played a greater role than semantic/syntactic network structure in GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 rating their own stories. These quantitative results underscore key limitations in the ability of GPT-3.5 and Sonnet 3.7 to align with human assessments of creativity. We emphasise the need for caution when using AI models to assess and generate creative content, as they may not yet capture the nuanced complexity that characterises human creativity.