The first quarter of 2020 heralded the beginning of an uncertain future for museums and galleries as the COVID-19 pandemic hit and the only means to stay ‘open’ was to turn towards the digital. In this paper, we investigate how the physical closure of museum buildings due to lockdown restrictions caused shockwaves within their digital strategies and changed their data practices potentially for good. We review the impact of COVID-19 on the museum sector, based on literature and desk research, with a focus on the implications for three museums and art galleries in the United Kingdom and the United States, and their mission, objectives, and digital data practices. We then present an analysis of ten qualitative interviews with expert witnesses working in the sector, representing different roles and types of institutions, undertaken between April and October 2020. Our research finds that digital engagement with museum content and practices around data in institutions have changed and that digital methods for organising and accessing collections for both staff and the general public have become more important. We present evidence that strategic preparedness influenced how well institutions were able to transition during closure and that metrics data became pivotal in understanding this novel situation. Increased engagement online changed traditional audience profiles, challenging museums to find ways of accommodating new forms of engagement in order to survive and thrive in the post-pandemic environment.
Beside reminiscing, the increasing cognitive decline in dementia can also be addressed through sensory stimulation allowing the immediate, nonverbal engagement with the world through one's senses. Much HCI work has prioritized cognitive stimulation for reminiscing or personhood often on small screens, while less research has explored sensory stimulation like the one enabled by large displays. We describe a year-long deployment in a residential care home of a wall-sized display, and explored its domestication through 24 contextual interviews. Findings indicate strong engagement and attachment to the display which has inspired four psychosocial interventions using online generic content. We discuss the value of these findings for personhood through residents' exercise of choices, the tension between generic/personal content and its public/private use, the importance of participatory research approach to domestication, and the infrastructure-based prototype, illustrated by the DementiaWall and its generative quality.
In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a rapid response from governments and researchers worldwide, but information-sharing mechanisms were variable, and many early efforts were insufficient for the purpose. We interviewed fifteen data professionals located around the world, working with COVID-19-relevant data types in semi-structured interviews. Interviews covered both challenges and positive experiences with data in multiple domains and formats, including medical records, social deprivation, hospital bed capacity, and mobility data. We analyze this qualitative corpus of experiences for content and themes and identify four sequential barriers a researcher may encounter. These are: (1) Knowing data exists, (2) being able to access that data, (3) data quality, and (4) ability to share data onwards. A fifth barrier, (5) human throughput capacity, is present throughout all four stages. Examples of these barriers range from challenges faced by single individuals to non-existent records of historic mingling/social distance laws, and up to systemic geopolitical data suppression. Finally, we recommend that governments and local authorities explicitly create machine-readable temporal “law as code” for changes in laws such as mobility/mingling laws and changes in geographical regions.
Background: Use of wearable vital signs sensors (WVSSs) to monitor hospitalised patients is growing but uncertainty exists about how such sensors should be adopted into existing practice. The aim of this observational study was to determine the completeness of data capture and accuracy of measurements recorded by a suite of WVSSs. The implications of using such measurements to derive early warning scores was also assessed. Methods: Adult inpatients with Covid-19 wore four WVSSs recording heart rate/respiratory rate (HR/RR), oxygen saturation (SpO2), axillary temperature and blood pressure (BP). Wearable vitals were paired with traditional vitals (measured by nurses) recorded concurrently. The accuracy of the wearable vitals was assessed using traditional vitals as the reference. National early warning (NEWS2) scores were calculated using wearable and traditional vitals. Results: Forty-eight patients were monitored for 204 days with the sensors. Median sensor wear was 3.9(IQR:1.7–5.9), 3.9(IQR:1.6–5.9) and 3.8(IQR:0.9–5.9) days for HR/RR, temperature and SpO2 respectively. The BP cuff was worn for median 1.9(IQR:0.9–3.8) days in 33 patients. Length of hospital stay was 8(IQR:6–13) days. Completeness of data capture was 84% for HR/RR, 98% for temperature, 72% for SpO2 and 36% for BP. There were 1633 HR, 1614 RR, 1412 temperature, 1294 SpO2 and 59 BP wearable-traditional measurement pairs. 59.7% of HR pairs were within ± 5 bpm, 38.5% of RR pairs within ± 3breaths/min, 24.4% of temperature pairs within ± 0.3℃, 32.9% of SpO2 pairs within ± 2% and 39.0% of BP pairs within ± 10 mmHg. Agreement between wearable and traditional RRs was poor at high RRs. In a ward setting, 613 NEWS2 scores were calculated using wearable-traditional HR, RR, temperature and SpO2 pairs. The median NEWS2traditional was 1(IQR:1–2) and the median NEWS2wearable was 4(IQR:3–6). Using traditional NEWS2 alerts as a reference, 86% (225/262) of wearable NEWS2 5 + alerts and 89% (82/92) of wearable NEWS2 7 + alerts were false positives. Conclusions: Agreement between vital signs recorded by wearable sensors and concurrent traditional vitals is poor. In this context, data from wearable sensors should not be used in existing track and trigger systems. Trial registration: The COSMIC-19 study was registered with clinicaltrials.gov (registration: NCT04581031, date of registration: Oct 6th 2020).
Openness and transparency in the research process are a prerequisite to the production of high quality research outputs. Efforts to maximise these features have substantially accelerated in recent years, placing open and transparent research practices at the forefront of funding and related priorities, and encouraging investment in resources and infrastructure to enable such practices. Despite these efforts, there has been no systematic documentation of current practices, infrastructure, or training and resources that support open and transparent research in the UK. To address this gap, we developed and conducted the Open and Transparent Research Practices survey, a large-scale audit study completed by research-active staff in UK research institutions to better understand existing practices, needs, support, and barriers faced when implementing open and transparent research. The data presented here capture responses from over 2,500 research-active staff based at 15 institutions affiliated with the UK Reproducibility Network. The data provide a snapshot of open research practices that can be used to identify barriers, training needs, and areas that require greater investments.
Objectives: To investigate clinicians’ attitudes towards current automated interpretation of ECG and novel AI technologies and their perception of computer-assisted interpretation. Materials and Methods: We conducted a series of interviews with clinicians in the UK. Our study: (1) explores the potential for AI, specifically future “human-like” computing approaches, to facilitate ECG interpretation and support clinical decision making, and (2) elicits their opinions about the importance of explainability and trustworthiness of AI algorithms. Results: We performed inductive thematic analysis on interview transcriptions from 23 clinicians and identified the following themes: (1) a lack of trust in current systems, (2) positive attitudes towards future AI applications and requirements for these, (3) the relationship between the accuracy and explainability of algorithms, and (4) opinions on education, possible deskilling, and the impact of AI on clinical competencies. Discussion: Clinicians do not trust current computerised methods, but welcome future “AI” technologies. Where clinicians trust future AI interpretation to be accurate, they are less concerned that it is explainable. They also preferred ECG interpretation that demonstrated the results of the algorithm visually. Whilst clinicians do not fear job losses, they are concerned about deskilling and the need to educate the workforce to use AI responsibly. Conclusion: Clinicians are positive about the future application of AI in clinical decision-making. Accuracy is a key factor of uptake and visualisations are preferred over current computerised methods. This is viewed as a potential means of training and upskilling, in contrast to the deskilling that automation might be perceived to bring.