Introduction: Previous cross-sectional research has shown that individuals’ appraisals of and emotional responses to health crisis-related news media use (i.e., media experiences) are associated with mental distress on average. However, little is known about longitudinal developments or how associations between multiple media experiences and mental distress vary across persons. The present study aims to bridge these gaps in current health communication research by adopting a longitudinal person-centered approach rather than a variable-centered method. Methods: Based on data from a three-wave panel survey ( n = 856) conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic, a longitudinal latent profile analysis was employed to identify subgroups with distinct trajectories of depressive symptoms and various media experiences (fear, uncertainty, fatigue, and trust). In addition, a multinomial logistic regression analysis was performed to examine individual predictors of subgroup membership. Results: The analysis identified six subgroups: 1) Continuously Trusting Resilients , 2) Fatigued-Trusting Resilients , 3) Rather Stable Average , 4) Fatigued-Distrusting Recoverers , 5) Anxious-Fatigued Responsive Vulnerables , and 6) Trusting-Fearful Chronic Vulnerables . Some subgroups exhibited parallel trajectories of depressive symptoms and media experiences, including stable and fluctuating patterns, whereas in others, depressive symptoms and media experiences developed rather divergently. Moreover, two potentially distressing patterns in media experiences were identified: 1) high and fluctuating fatigue, fear, and uncertainty, and 2) high and persistent trust and fear. Individuals who were female, had lower psychological resilience, and were more strongly affected by the pandemic's social consequences had an increased likelihood of belonging to both groups. Moreover, younger adults were more likely to belong to the subgroup characterized by the trust–fear pattern, while infrequent use of public television was associated with membership in the subgroup showing the fatigue–uncertainty–fear pattern. Discussion: Practically, these findings highlight the need for resilience-building interventions that incorporate media-related components tailored to the demands of different audiences.