11 January 2024 in Citizen Science: Theory and Practice
Nature conservation–related citizen science (NCCS) has grown rapidly worldwide in previous years. In Hungary, a few citizen science (CS) projects have been operating for years and some have only recently launched. Our aim herein is to assess the performance of eight Hungarian NCCS projects in three dimensions: a) science, b) nature conservation, and c) participants’ development. An evaluation framework was developed for the assessment. Our results show that the Common Bird Monitoring Program performed the best overall. This is also the oldest NCCS project in the country. When comparing the performance per dimension, the majority of the projects tended to have good performances in the science dimension. Most of the projects ensure data quality using different strategies. However, the need for open data and processing the project results for generating scientific publications still needs to be tackled by some NCCS initiatives. Regarding the nature conservation dimension, data generated have been mostly used in monitoring species/ecosystems, whereas data is less commonly used for conservation policy-making. It was identified that the participants’ development dimension has not received sufficient attention, and neither learning outcomes nor behavioral and attitude change has been evaluated by any projects. Our results of evaluating Hungarian NCCS initiatives in a complex way may offer insights for project managers and coordinators to identify which dimension are performing well and which areas need improvement. Also, our framework serves as a model that can be applied to current and future NCCS initiatives.
20 December 2024 in Review on Agriculture and Rural Development
The necessity of expanding our understanding of how Nature Conservation Citizen Science projects contribute to decision-making is frequently emphasized in related scientific studies. A literature review was conducted about the impacts of NCCS projects on policy and decision-making. Peer-reviewed scientific papers published between 2014 and 2024 were used to identify: a) the forms that NCSS projects affected conservation policy, b) the most frequent strategies used in the studies to determine that impact and c) the common challenges encountered for affecting policy. Our results show that more than half of the reviewed publications mention that projects begin with aspirations to make a meaningful contribution to conservation policy, but they rarely share their data with official databases (e.g. official monitoring systems at the local, national, or global levels that implement governmental policy). Our results also show that NCCS projects tend to inform decision-making at early policy stages (e.g. informing policy) and are less common at later phases (e.g. formulation or implementation). Case studies and surveys were most often used to determine the effect. To truly influence national conservation policies, improving channels to communicate with decision-makers is needed and challenges with improving data quality to ensure scientific rigor also need to be addressed.