This article challenges the categorization of smugglers as wicked villains by exploring smuggling’s moral economy. I present findings from two years of ethnographic field research on Syrian refugees and smugglers in Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, Italy, and along the so-called Balkan route (Greece, Macedonia, and Serbia). The relationship between the smugglers and the migrants appeared to be rich in solidarity and reciprocity and grounded in local notions of morality. Far from the dominant official narrative in the West of reckless criminals driven only by profit, smugglers sought and often found moral legitimation by using long-held notions of morality and religious duties when confronting the risky realities of their illicit enterprise.
21 February 2018 in The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
In this volume of The ANNALS, we present a collection of empirically based research projects on migrant smuggling, seeking to create a more nuanced understanding of the topic that supersedes perspectives that are often found in mainstream narratives of unscrupulous and ruthless criminal gangs preying on vulnerable and desperate migrants. The contributing authors rely on field data to reveal the complex and often symbiotic relationships between migrants and the people behind their journeys. Often misunderstood in juxtaposition to narratives of security and control, the lived experiences of migrants describe smuggling facilitators as relatives or close friends, acquaintances or distant operators—all members of a social network of varying relational proximity. Vulnerability in migration grows as the travel distance and transit points increase and the density of one’s own community ties decreases. The procurement of smuggling services is always situated within the collective wisdom and lived experiences of the migrants and their communities, and the strategies to increase the odds of success and to reduce the hazards and uncertainty of traversing foreign terrains.
In al-Wihdat, a Palestinian refugee camp in Jordan, there is today a puzzling absence of political participation among camp dwellers. This absence is all the more striking for a number of reasons. First of all, because Palestinian refugee camps in the Middle East are widely held to be bastions of political resistance and Palestinian nationalism. Secondly, because this lack of political participation coincides with the outbreak of unprecedented turmoil in the Arab world. Is refugees’ disengagement from politics a clear sign of their passive assimilation or, conversely, a form of political protest tout court? What forms does Palestinian nationalism take in a country that has granted full citizenship rights to the majority of refugees? More generally, how do claims of national belonging articulate with other, apparently conflicting, national identities? Taking as its starting point the reverberations of the “Arab Spring” in Jordan, this paper wants to shed light on the complexities associated with refugees’ socioeconomic and political integration in Jordan. More broadly, it aims to add to a scholarly debate that has recently urged anthropologists and social scientists to rethink the categories of “the political” and “political agency.” What will be argued here is that refugees’ eagerness to distance themselves from what they saw as the dangerous world of politics can also be explained with Carl Schmitt’s specific understanding of the political. According to the philosopher, the distinction between friend and enemy lies at the very core of “the political.” In Jordan, this distinction is played out in the seemingly contradiction of being both Palestinian refugees and Jordanian citizens. However, if politics requires taking a firm stand either as Palestinian refugees or Jordanian citizens that camp dwellers are unwilling to take, a descent into what refugee perceives as a nonpolitical ordinariness enables them to negotiate the complexities of their lives.
27 April 2015 in International Journal of Middle East Studies
This article explores the complex interplay between masculinity and nationalism among Palestinians living in a refugee camp in Jordan. Youth masculinity in the camp is widely perceived in Jordan as an expression of either immoral behavior or unthinking radicalism, and as a symbol of cultural and political difference and the failure of camp dwellers to embrace assimilation. However, camp dwellers’ masculinities are not uniform. I argue that young men's ability to navigate and master diverse and sometimes contrasting registers of manhood enables them to reproduce a Palestinian national identity in exile while achieving socioeconomic integration in Jordan. In pursuing this argument, the article has two goals: to challenge popular stereotypes about Palestinian refugees in Jordan today; and to problematize the discursive mutual dependency between nationalism and hegemonic masculinity in the study of Palestinian masculinity.
According to mainstream media and political discourse, human smugglers are among the cruellest figures of our time, individuals who prey on migrants’ need for assistance. Motivated by the circulation of this pejorative view in media and political discourse, I carried out ethnographic research with Syrian refugees and smugglers in Turkey, Greece, Jordan, and Lebanon with the ultimate goal of documenting what being a smuggler entails for the very actors of this unfolding drama. Fieldwork showed me how human smuggling was rooted in patterns of cooperation and support. And yet, most if not all my interlocutors, including the “smugglers” themselves, spoke of smuggling in negative terms. What I argue in this paper is that the smuggler, a category functional to the security apparatus, is not only manufactured within law enforcement circles and mainstream media, but even by those very people who are discriminated or targeted by states’ migration policies.
11 June 2024 in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies