9 December 2023 in Technology in Society
20 November 2022 in Internet Research
Purpose: There is a scarcity of research studies on why people remain inactive when encountering and recognising misinformation online. The main aim of this paper is to provide a groundwork for future research into why users do not challenge misinformation on digital platforms by generating hypotheses through a synthesis of pertinent literature, including organisational behaviour, communication, human-computer interaction (HCI), psychology and education.Design/methodology/approach: Given the lack of directly related literature, this paper synthesised findings from relevant fields where the findings might be relevant, as the tendency to withhold opinions or feedback is a well-documented practice in offline interaction.Findings: Following the analysis of relevant literature, the potential reasons for online silence towards misinformation can be divided into six categories: self-oriented, relationship-oriented, others-oriented, content-oriented, individual characteristics and technical factors.Originality/value: Although corrections coming from peers can effectively combat misinformation, several studies showed that people in cyberspace do not take such action. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, there has been scarce and virtually non-existent research investigating why people refrain from challenging others who post misinformation online. Thus, this paper attempts to address this gap and identify reasons in adjacent domains. The reasons provide a starting point for researching interventions to reduce reluctance and abstinence regarding the challenge of misinformation. The findings can be beneficial beyond the area of challenging misinformation and are extensible to other types of content and communication that people are hesitant to discuss and challenge, such as online injustice, prejudice and hate speech.
1 January 2024 in Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies
The spread of misinformation on social media is a critical issue. One potential solution to mitigate the spread is user corrections; however, users often refrain due to various concerns. Leveraging the established influence of user interface design (UID) on how user interact with and respond to misinformation, this study investigates how user interface features can be designed to motivate users to challenge misinformation. It is aimed at gaining insights into users’ needs and UID requirements that encourage this behaviour. We conducted four codesign sessions with 18 social media users (age range 20–60 years M = 39.1; 10 female and 8 male). We applied the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology (UTAUT) as a theoretical framework and analysed our data based on the core constructs of this framework: performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, and facilitating conditions. Our findings reveal four design considerations: creating secure and supportive environments, facilitating informed discussions through easy confrontation and access to reliable resources, leveraging recognition and social proof, and user support infrastructure. We also identified specific design elements with users, including indirection, semianonymity and privacy, simplicity, one‐click challenging, easy access to reliable sources, recognition, displaying social proof, and platform support. These elements are aimed at reducing social discomfort and making the process of correcting misinformation more approachable for users. Our findings offer actionable insights for social media platform designers to reduce the spread of misinformation by creating environments that encourage constructive dialogues and allow users to challenge misinformation without fear of conflict.
4 May 2023 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Our survey included 250 UK-based social media users and aimed to identify the factors that contribute to users’ reluctance to challenge misinformation. The study found that people have misperceptions about the negative consequences of challenging misinformation and the acceptability of the behaviour. The negative consequences were categorized into three categories: relationship consequences, negative impact on others, and futility. Participants perceived higher relationship consequences and futility for others than themselves. Additionally, people anticipate more negative reactions from others when being challenged for sharing misinformation than they themselves expect. Those who believed that others think challenging misinformation is more socially acceptable than themselves were more likely to challenge. Moreover, age, injunctive norms and perceived negative impact on others have an impact on willingness to challenge. Overall, the study underscores the significance of understanding the role of perceptions and misperceptions in challenging misinformation. Developing features on social media that facilitate challenging misinformation or fostering social norms that endorse it can address these misperceptions. To develop the right approach understanding of users and their motivations is crucial. Our study paves the way for the development of effective user-centric countermeasures by shedding light about user’s attitudes, perceptions and misperceptions.