Since holistic scoring leaves room for multiple solutions and creativity, it seems an efficient and effective way to evaluate student performance. However, in practice, there are different views of what holistic scoring entails, what matching instruments look like, and how they should be designed to reap the benefits and avoid the drawbacks. Guidelines for holistic scoring processes seem to be lacking. Therefore, this systematic literature review, executed following the PRISMA model, conceptualised holistic scoring and derived design guidelines from the literature to improve the assessment quality of holistic scoring. The review included 163 publications. The synthesis of the studies has resulted in a definition of holistic scoring, grounded in the various characteristics identified across the different studies. In addition, it identifies various advantages and disadvantages of holistic scoring, along with a wide range of instruments currently employed in its implementation. Twelve guidelines have been formulated, each addressing distinct aspects such as the selection and design of the instrument, the training of assessors, and the involvement of stakeholders in the design process. Finally, the review outlines implications for future research, such as the application of holistic scoring on a program level and the exploration of students' experiences when being assessed holistically. Context and implications: Rationale for this study: Although general assessment guidelines exist, specific guidance for holistic scoring is lacking. Why the new findings matter: In higher education, tasks increasingly require students to demonstrate integrated competencies, highlighting holistic scoring. Clear guidelines for holistic scoring are crucial to help educators make valid, reliable, and transparent decisions about student performances. Implications for educational advisors, teachers, and policymakers: The newly developed guidelines for holistic scoring provide essential support for educational advisors and teachers. They offer a clear framework for designing, implementing, and evaluating integrated assessment tasks, enhancing validity, reliability, and transparency. Ultimately, these guidelines enable educators to assess students' competencies in a coherent and equitable manner, fostering transparent and evidence‐informed assessment practices.