Intervention studiescombiningcognitive and motor demands have reported far-transfer cognitive benefits in healthy ageing. This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated the effects of music and rhythm intervention on cognition in older adulthood. Inclusion criteria specified: 1) musical instrument training; 2) healthy, musically-naïve adults (≥60 years); 3) control group; 4) measure of executive function. Ovid, PubMed, Scopus and the Cochrane Library online databases were searched in August 2023. Data from thirteen studies were analysed (N = 502 participants). Study quality was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool (RoB 2; Sterne et al., 2019). Random effects models revealed: a low effect on inhibition (d = 0.27,p = .0335); a low-moderate effect on switching (d = -0.39, p = .0021); a low-moderate effect on verbal category switching (d =0.39,p = .0166); and a moderate effect on processing speed (d = 0.47,p < .0001). No effect was found for selective visual attention, working memory, or verbal memory. With regards to overall bias, three studies were rated as "high", nine studies were rated as having "some concerns" and one was rated "low". The meta-analysis suggests that learning to play a musical instrument enhances attention inhibition, switching and processing speed in ageing.
17 March 2022 in Neuropsychological Rehabilitation
Reliable remote cognitive testing could provide a safer assessment of cognitive impairment in multiple sclerosis (MS) during the COVID-19 pandemic and thereafter. Here we aimed to investigate the reliability and feasibility of administering Brief International Cognitive Assessment for MS (BICAMS) and the Trail-Making Test (TMT) to people with MS online. Between-group differences on BICAMS and the TMT were examined in a sample of 68 participants. Group 1 (N = 34) was tested in-person pre-pandemic. Group 2 was tested remotely. Within-group differences for in-person and virtual administrations were examined for Group 1. No significant differences between virtual and in-person administrations of the CVLT-II and SDMT were detected. BVMT-R scores were significantly higher for virtual administrations (M = 20.59, SD= 6.65) compared to in-person administrations (M = 16.35, SD= 6.05), possibly indicating inter-rater differences. Strong positive correlations were found for in-person and virtual scores within Group 1 on the CVLT-II (r = .84), SDMT (r = .85), TMT-A (r = .88), TMT-B (r = .76) and BVMT-R (r = .72). No significant differences between in-person and remote administrations of CVLT-II and SDMT in people living with MS were detected. Recommendations for future studies employing the TMT and BVMT-R online are provided.
2 June 2022 in Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications
The process of trial recruitment is vital, given its impact on resources, statistical power and the validity of findings. A participant information leaflet (PIL) is often the initial and primary source of information engaged by potential participants during recruitment. Research suggests that a variety of manipulations to a PIL can be made during its development to enhance understanding, readability and accessibility. In light of this, PIL-design led by Public and Patient Involvement (PPI) may also yield positive effects in this respect, as well as consent and retention. This study-within-a-trial (SWAT) compared the effects of a PPI-developed PIL with a standard, researcher-developed PIL on rates of consent, retention, decision certainty, understanding, readability, accessibility, likeability and decision to consent. This SWAT used a double-blind, two-armed randomised design. The SWAT was conducted within a host trial of cognitive rehabilitation in multiple sclerosis. A total of 234 people expressed interest in the trial, of which 94 were retained at 6-month follow up. Results revealed no effects on levels of consent and retention between the two PIL groups. These null effects provide interesting points of discussion and important implications for not only future research on PILs, but also for future research that involves recruitment to health-related interventions.
Introduction: There is a high prevalence of cognitive difficulties in MS, but despite this, there are few programmes targeting cognition that focus on the ability to function well in everyday life. The Cognitive Occupation-Based programme for people with Multiple Sclerosis (COB-MS), an occupation-focused cognitive intervention, was developed to address this. It addresses both the functional difficulties and the wide-ranging symptoms that present in MS. Objective: Here we report on the results of a cluster-randomised controlled feasibility trial (ISRCTN11462710; registered 4th September 2019) evaluating the COB-MS in terms of feasibility and initial efficacy as a cognitive intervention for people with MS. Method: The eight-session COB-MS intervention was delivered remotely by occupational therapists to participants with MS in the intervention group. Following the end of the trial the COB-MS was delivered to the wait-list control group. Data was collected from people with MS experiencing cognitive difficulties at baseline, post-intervention, 12-weeks, and 6-month follow-up. The primary outcome measure was the Goal Attainment Scaling at 12 weeks. Data was also collected in the domains of cognition, quality of life, and mood. Results: One hundred and eighteen people with MS and cognitive difficulties were randomised to either usual care (n = 60) or COB-MS intervention (n = 58). Ninety-four participants were retained at 6-month follow-up. The COB-MS was found to be feasible, including trial procedures and protocol. Data indicates that the COB-MS is accepted by participants and had positive impacts on daily life. Those allocated to the COB-MS group had a significant improvement in the primary outcome compared to the control condition. Progression criteria set for the feasibility trial have been met therefore further testing of the COB-MS at a definitive trial is supported by the results. Conclusion: The results provide a strong basis for a pathway to a future definitive trial of COB-MS, with respect to both feasibility and preliminary, clinical efficacy. Trial Registration: ISRCTN11462710 Date of registration: 4th September 2019.
Background: Ageing is associated with a loss of fluid intelligence and motor functions which hamper independence and quality of life. Training in a musical instrument can improve fluid intelligence and executive function (EF) in older non-musicians but the neural correlates underpinning the benefits remain elusive. The primary aims of this study are to: i) test the acceptability of Piano Instruction for Adult Novices as Online Cognitive Intervention (PIANO-Cog), a novel bespoke 8-week self-guided piano training programme for adults over the age of 50 years; and ii) to test the feasibility (in terms of recruitment, retention and adherence) of a large scale RCT comparing PIANO-Cog to a passive control. Secondary aims of this study are: i) to investigate the effects of online piano training on fluid abilities, EF and motor function; ii) to investigate training-induced microstructural brain changes using ultra-strong gradient (300mT/m) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and iii) to investigate how the latter may be linked to cognitive improvements post-training. Method: A two-armed unblinded RCT will be conducted on 50 healthy non-musician adults over the age of 50. Participants will be randomised to a piano training (PT) or passive control group for 8 weeks, stratified for age and sex. PT participants will receive a training manual and 20-min video tutorials each week, and will practice 30 min, 5 days per week. Control participants will receive no intervention for the 8-week period. Cognitive testing and MRI of the brain will take place before and after the intervention. Discussion: The primary aim of the trial is to determine the acceptability of PIANO-Cog as an online cognitive intervention for adults over 50 who are non-musicians, and the feasibility of conducting a large-scale RCT in terms of recruitment, retention and adherence. Self-guided music training programmes could provide a cost-effective method of maintaining or improving cognitive and motor functions that individuals can implement in their own homes. Secondary aims are regarding the investigation of positive transfer of piano training to EF and fluid abilities in ageing, and to provide evidence for the relationship between training-induced cognitive enhancements and underlying white and grey matter microstructural changes. Trial registration: ISRCTN11023869 (retrospectively registered). Protocol version: 20/10/2025 version 1.5