Icebreaking is a recurring yet insufficiently examined element of workshops reported at the CHI conference proceedings. It is often introduced to ease social barriers, foster trust, and stimulate participation. Across papers, icebreaking takes diverse forms such as onboarding exercises, reflective sharing, exploratory probes, and role play. However, the concept remains inconsistently defined, its reporting is often limited, and its contribution to collaboration and design outcomes has rarely been discussed or evaluated in detail. We reviewed 376 CHI conference proceedings from 2015 to 2025, of which 93 explicitly describe or can be identified as involving icebreaking activities. Through thematic coding, we classified practices by purpose, format, facilitation strategy, and reported outcome. Findings highlight both the ubiquity and under-theorization of icebreaking, yet it is rarely treated as a designable element. We conclude with methodological reflections that frame icebreaking as a designable and context-sensitive practice in future workshops.