Susanne Mak

Susanne Mak

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Susanne Mak

School of Physical & Occupational Therapy, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

11Years (2016-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 October 2022 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SMSusanne Mak
Susanne Mak
ATAliki Thomas
Aliki Thomas
A scoping review is a type of knowledge synthesis that uses a systematic and iterative approach to identify and synthesize an existing or emerging body of literature on a given topic.1 While there are several reasons for conducting a scoping review, the main reasons are to map the extent, range, and nature of the literature, as well as to determine possible gaps in the literature on a topic.1-3 Scoping reviews are not limited to peer-reviewed literature.3,4Before conducting the review, it is important to consider the composition of the research team: scoping reviews are not conducted by a single individual. The team should include someone with content expertise and an individual with experience conducting scoping reviews.1,3,5 Adding a librarian who can assist with building the search strategy is also extremely helpful.1,3 Thoughtful planning of the team membership will result in the right knowledge, skills, and expertise to successfully complete the review and ensure that the findings make a notable contribution to the field.An overview of the steps involved in conducting scoping reviews is provided below.Creating the research question is a vital first step.1,3-5 A question that is too broad increases the number of papers for consideration, which may affect the feasibility of the review.5 A question that is too narrow may compromise the breadth and depth of the review. Therefore, a preliminary search of the literature may be helpful in determining: (1) the breadth of your question; (2) whether a scoping review on the topic has already been conducted; and (3) if there is sufficient literature to warrant a scoping review. Consulting with a librarian can help in deciding if a scoping review is the appropriate review method.1,3 In particular, a librarian may confirm that there is insufficient literature or that there is too much, which will necessitate a more targeted research question.Early consultation with a librarian should occur to build the search strategy—keywords, Medical Subject Headings, databases—and further refine the strategy based on the papers found. For example, you may find too many irrelevant papers. In this case you may need to review your search strategy to identify the terms which introduce too much “noise.”You will also need to define the inclusion and exclusion criteria.1,3-5 Discussions with your team are important to ensure diverse perspectives and that the inclusion criteria are aligned with the research question.5,6Tools such as Covidence and Rayyan can be helpful in organizing papers and making the screening process more efficient (Box). Once you have collected the citations from the search, you can import these from reference management software (eg, EndNote) into Rayyan. After selecting papers for inclusion, the citations of the included papers can be exported to reference management software for the next stage of the review. Other helpful features of management software can include the identification of duplicates, proportion of an abstract that resembles another, and documentation of reasons for inclusion or exclusion. Both Covidence and Rayyan allow for blinding the results of team members' reviews to each other.Having additional reviewers will accelerate the pace of the review but will require calibration between reviewers.1,3,5 A calibration exercise consists of selecting 5% to 10% of the papers for independent screening by each reviewer.1 If a high level of agreement among reviewers is not achieved (eg, lower than 90%),7,8 the reviewers should discuss their points of disagreement and review (and possibly revise) the inclusion criteria.1 Another 10% of the papers are then selected for a second calibration exercise to test the modified inclusion criteria. If having 2 reviewers for each paper is not feasible, one reviewer can conduct an independent review, with a second reviewer verifying a portion of the papers, with the goal of 90% or better agreement.The actual screening of papers should consist of reading not only the title of the paper, but the abstract as well. If an abstract is not available, a full-text review of the paper is required. Screening papers by title alone is insufficient, as the contents of a paper are not always well reflected in the title.The team develops the data extraction form collaboratively. Although the extraction categories vary depending on the research question and review purpose, common categories are: author, year, geographical location, study population, main results, study limitations, and future directions.4,5 More specific categories will be needed to capture the data for a given research question.The extraction form will need to be pilot tested for further refinements and undergo a calibration exercise as well.1,3,5 This entails a dyad of reviewers independently extracting data from a small number of papers (eg, 5-10), and meeting afterward to discuss any discrepancies, with further refinement of the form if a high level of agreement between reviewers is not obtained.Once the data have been extracted from all papers, numerical and thematic analyses are conducted.5 The findings from the numerical analysis can be presented in a table or chart to showcase the most salient aspects of the review. Readers should be able to see alignment of findings with objectives for conducting the review.1,3 Thematic analysis9 consists of examining excerpts of text and asking how this text relates to the research question, as well as creating a code (label) that best reflects that text. A list of tentative codes (a codebook) is created and modified iteratively as the team engages in data analysis. Once codes are developed, a review of the codes and how they relate to each other can help to identify patterns among them, which leads to the creation of categories (collections of similar data in one place)10 and themes (patterns across the dataset).9Reflexivity is essential throughout the review process but...

1 October 2022 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SMSusanne Mak
Susanne Mak
ATAliki Thomas
Aliki Thomas
The number of medical education scoping reviews has been on the rise for the past few decades.1 A recent bibliometric analysis of knowledge syntheses, published in 14 core health professions education (HPE) journals, from 1999 to 2019, identified scoping reviews as the second most prevalent type of knowledge synthesis.2 Researchers use scoping reviews to map the depth and breadth of emerging areas in medical education,2-4 allowing them to include different forms of literature and thus not be limited to peer-reviewed literature.4-6 Scoping review teams must use a systematic and rigorous approach to produce a synthesis of the common concepts identified in the diverse existing literature.Why choose a scoping review over another knowledge synthesis approach? A 2020 paper by Peters and colleagues outlined reasons for conducting a scoping review and highlighted 6 key reasons (Box 1).4 The selection of a knowledge synthesis approach depends on the nature of the research question and the aims of the project. Examples of research questions could be: “What is known about professional identity and professional identity formation in the rehabilitation professions”7 or “How is clinical reasoning described in the HPE literature?”8 The amount of existing literature in the area of interest is also an important consideration. A scoping review method requires sufficient existing literature on the topic. Consider a topic such as clinical reasoning, which has been explored with different methods and in different professions.8 A scoping review could be useful for providing a map of what has been studied about the topic (eg, purpose or goal of reasoning, reasoning performance).8 The findings of such a scoping review would allow a reader to understand the scope of the existing studies and what the authors learned about the topic, as well as to identify gaps in the literature and their recommendations for future areas of scholarship.8 The example with Dr. Smith (Box 2) illustrates how conducting a scoping review will allow her to develop an understanding of the concepts of interprofessional education related to her speciality, setting, and trainee level, as well as to determine future lines of inquiry. Therefore, scoping review methods are well-suited to investigate questions of an exploratory nature and can be a starting point for other empirical inquiries.It is important to note that there are misconceptions about scoping reviews.4 One common misconception is that they are viewed as less rigorous, quicker, or easier to implement than other forms of reviews. However, as with any review, a research team that conducts a scoping review in a thoughtful and rigorous manner will ensure a strong contribution to the field of study.3Scoping reviews are aligned with HPE interpretivist and constructivist paradigms, which derive from an epistemological foundation that disputes an absolute truth. Rather, it embraces the creation of new knowledge through the connections between the research team, the team's knowledge and past experiences, the data, and the topic of interest.9 Therefore, an iterative approach is used, in which inclusion criteria may be refined during the processes of screening abstracts and full-text papers for inclusion and data analysis.A researcher who decides to conduct a scoping review should consider the epistemological foundations of this type of review and reflect on the alignment between their own worldviews and those of scoping review methods. The iterative and flexible nature of a scoping review aligns well with the constructivist and interpretivist paradigms that are at the core of several qualitative traditions.2,9,10 Therefore, a researcher who embraces other paradigms (eg positivist) should consider exercising reflexivity throughout the research process to ensure their perspectives and methods align with the paradigms of a scoping review.2,9,10The epistemological foundation of scoping reviews allows for selection and inclusion of articles from a broad array of literature types (eg, grey literature); as such, it is not limited to peer-reviewed literature.9 The methodological approach of scoping reviews enables the research team to cast a wide net, to capture all the literature available on a given topic (breadth), and therefore, to map and synthesize the literature on the topic of interest. However, the breadth captured by scoping reviews will also produce findings that may be more nuanced. Thus, a team approach to data analysis will be essential to identify the patterns and divergences in the codes and categories.The subjective nature of scoping reviews also means that researchers are required to make decisions based on defensible arguments aligned with the subjectivist nature of the review.2,10 For example, during data analysis, researchers often reflect on their own perspectives and beliefs on a topic and how this may shape their interpretation of the data extracted from the literature. Therefore, researchers who conduct scoping reviews need to engage in reflexivity throughout the process to question their own decisions and how they arrived at those decisions.2,9Scoping reviews offer several advantages. First, a scoping review produces a synthesis of an existing and evolving body of literature to determine gaps in the literature and identify areas for future empirical work.4 The iterative nature of scoping reviews, aligned with the interpretivist and constructivist paradigms of qualitative HPE approaches,9 is well-suited to the exploratory research questions often posed in this field. Due to this orientation, scoping reviews allow the inclusion of different types of literature. While scoping reviews do include original studies that yield empirical evidence, they may also include grey literature such as dissertations, papers in practice journals, editorials, position statements, and websites.2,4Scoping reviews also provide an opportunity for stakeholder...

25 April 2022 in Advances in Health Sciences Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SMSusanne Mak
Susanne Mak
MHMatthew Hunt
Matthew Hunt
JBJill Boruff
Jill Boruff
MZMarco Zaccagnini
Marco Zaccagnini
ATAliki Thomas
Aliki Thomas

31 March 2023 in Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SMSusanne Msc Mak
Susanne Msc Mak
MHMatthew Hunt
Matthew Hunt
SRSerena Speranza Msc Riccio
Serena Speranza Msc Riccio
SRSaleem Md Razack
Saleem Md Razack
KRKelly Msc Root
Kelly Msc Root
ATAliki PhD Thomas
Aliki PhD Thomas
Introduction: Attrition is defined as a permanent departure from one's profession or the workforce. Existing literature on retention strategies, contributing factors to the attrition of rehabilitation professionals and how different environments influence professionals' decision-making to stay in/leave their profession, is limited in scope and specificity. The objective of our review was to map the depth and breadth of the literature on attrition and retention of rehabilitation professionals. Methods: We used Arksey and O'Malley's methodological framework. A search was conducted on MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase (Ovid), AMED, CINAHL, Scopus, and ProQuest Dissertations and Theses from 2010 to April 2021 for concepts of attrition and retention in occupational therapy, physical therapy, and speech-language pathology. Results: Of the 6031 retrieved records, 59 papers were selected for data extraction. Data were organized into three themes: (1) descriptions of attrition and retention, (2) experiences of being a professional, and (3) experiences in institutions where rehabilitation professionals work. Seven factors across three levels (individual, work, and environment) were found to influence attrition. Discussion: Our review showcases a vast, yet superficial array of literature on attrition and retention of rehabilitation professionals. Differences exist between occupational therapy, physical therapy, and speech-language pathology with respect to the focus of the literature. Push, pull, and stay factors would benefit from further empirical investigation to develop targeted retention strategies. These findings may help to inform health care institutions, professional regulatory bodies, and associations, as well as professional education programs, to develop resources to support retention of rehabilitation professionals.

1 December 2022 in Advances in Health Sciences Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MZMarco Zaccagnini
Marco Zaccagnini
ABAndré Bussières
André Bussières
SMSusanne Mak
Susanne Mak
JBJill Boruff
Jill Boruff
AWAndrew West
Andrew West
ATAliki Thomas
Aliki Thomas

31 May 2016 in Canadian Respiratory Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SMSusanne Mak
Susanne Mak
JSJudith E. Soicher
Judith E. Soicher
NMNancy E. Mayo
Nancy E. Mayo
SWSharon Wood-Dauphinee
Sharon Wood-Dauphinee
JBJean Bourbeau
Jean Bourbeau
Physical activity is difficult to measure in individuals with COPD. The Community Healthy Activities Model Program for Seniors (CHAMPS) questionnaire demonstrated strong clinometric properties when used with the elderly and with those affected by chronic disease. Study objectives were to translate, culturally adapt the CHAMPS into French, and reexamine its test-retest reliability and construct validity in French and English Canadians with COPD. This paper presents the cross-cultural adaptation of the CHAMPS; results of its clinometric testing will be described in another article. The CHAMPS examines the degree of physical activity performed in a typical week through two summary scales, caloric expenditure and activity frequency. The CHAMPS was only in English; thus, a cross-cultural adaptation was needed to translate the CHAMPS into French for use in French Canadians with COPD. Cross-cultural adaptation consisted of forward and back translation, with expert review at each stage of translation: minor inconsistencies were uncovered and rectified. Five French participants with COPD completed the finalized Canadian French CHAMPS and participated in cognitive debriefing; no problematic items were identified. A structured and stepwise, cross-cultural adaptation process produced the Canadian French CHAMPS, with items of equivalent meaning to the English version, for use in French Canadians with COPD.