An in-depth knowledge of the interaction of water with amorphous silica is critical to fundamental studies of interfacial hydration water, as well as to industrial processes such as catalysis, nanofabrication, and chromatography. Silica has a tunable surface comprising hydrophilic silanol groups and moderately hydrophobic siloxane groups that can be interchanged through thermal and chemical treatments. Despite extensive studies of silica surfaces, the influence of surface hydrophilicity and chemical topology on the molecular properties of interfacial water is not well understood. In this work, we controllably altered the surface silanol density, and measured surface water diffusivity using Overhauser dynamic nuclear polarization (ODNP) and complementary silica–silica interaction forces across water using a surface forces apparatus (SFA). The results show that increased silanol density generally leads to slower water diffusivity and stronger silica–silica repulsion at short aqueous separations (less than ∼4 nm). Both techniques show sharp changes in hydration properties at intermediate silanol densities (2.0–2.9 nm−2). Molecular dynamics simulations of model silica–water interfaces corroborate the increase in water diffusivity with silanol density, and furthermore show that even on a smooth and crystalline surface at a fixed silanol density, adjusting the spatial distribution of silanols results in a range of surface water diffusivities spanning ∼10%. We speculate that a critical silanol cluster size or connectivity parameter could explain the sharp transition in our results, and can modulate wettability, colloidal interactions, and surface reactions, and thus is a phenomenon worth further investigation on silica and chemically heterogeneous surfaces. Significance Silica, conventionally known as “glass,” is a universally used material in catalysis, nanofabrication, and many other applications, but details of its surface chemistry and interactions with water are notoriously complicated and unclear––partially due to its tunable surface chemistry. We utilize this tunable surface chemistry of silica to reveal properties of surface-bound water that impact surface reactions, adhesion, and colloidal interactions. Using a combination of surface forces, hydration dynamics, and simulation techniques, we show that surface silanol groups stabilize the surface water layer, and also that variations/fluctuations are more pronounced at intermediate silanol densities on the surface. This work provides insight into fundamental interactions of water with chemically heterogeneous surfaces.