14 December 2017 in Quality of Life Research
Purpose Economic evaluation of services and interventions in care services tends to focus on quality of life(QoL) based on health-related measures such as EQ5D, with a major focus on health and functioning. The Capability Approach (CA) provides an alternative framework for measuring QoL and challenges some of the conventional issues in the current practice of measurement of QoL. The Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit (ASCOT) aims to measure social care-related QoL in a broad sense. This article investigates whether and, if so, how the ASCOT addresses issues put on the agenda by the CA. Methods Literature analysis concerning theoretical assumptions and arguments of CA and ASCOT. Results The Capability Approach (CA) puts three issues on the agenda regarding QoL. First, the focus of evaluation should not be on functioning, but on freedom of choice. Second, evaluation should be critical about adaptive preferences, which entail that people lower expectations in situations of limited possibilities. Third, evaluation should not only address health, but also other domains of life. Our analysis shows that freedom of choice is reflected in the response option ‘as I want’ in the ASCOT questionnaire. The problem of adaptive preferences is countered in the ASCOT by developing a standard based on preferences of the general population. Third, the ASCOT contains several domains of life. Conclusions We conclude that the CA and the ASCOT contribute to the discussion on QoL, and that the ASCOT operationalizes core assumptions of the CA, translating the issues raised by the CA in a practical way.
6 March 2023 in OSF Preprints
In this position paper several observations on the current status quo of training and teaching in research integrity (RI) are being made. This leads to seven statements on what the challenges to training RI, rather preferred to be conceived as training in responsible conduct of research (RCR) and what is needed to meet these challenges.
23 June 2026 in Educational Psychology Review
Education in Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) aims to foster good research practices. Little, however, is known about how educators measure the impact of their courses, which outcome measures are used and if and how they are validated. In this review, we systematically identify measures used to evaluate RCR education and assess if and how they have been validated. We also analyse a selected subset of these measures. Specifically, those that include supporting evidence of validity and focus on research practices, in order to identify which Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) concepts they address and which learning outcomes they are designed to assess. In total, 162 articles were included, of which 46 articles contained information about a measure described as ‘validated’. Measures from these articles (and four additional measures suggested by experts) were assessed on accessibility, evidence of validation, and content related to research practice, resulting in 15 unique outcome measures with supporting validation evidence. All contained items covering topics which we categorised as pertaining to ‘research integrity’, whereas a smaller selection contained items covering topics which we categorised as pertaining to ‘research ethics’. Whilst all 15 reported at least some form of reliability or validity evidence, only 3 met what we describe as ‘strong’ validation evidence. Our review revealed that the majority of RCR education evaluations in the published literature have not used measures related to research conduct with reported validation evidence. The comprehensive overview we provide can offer guidance for educators and researchers to select, or further develop measures aligned with core RCR competencies and targeted learning outcomes.
29 September 2025 in Cogent Education
1 September 2021 in Home Health Care Services Quarterly
The aim was to investigate the views of stakeholders on the practical relevance of a broad quality of life (QoL) outcome tool for care in older adults: the Extended Quality of Life Tool (EQLT). We conducted individual interviews and focus groups with a variety of stakeholders involved in the care for older adults which were analyzed using a framework analysis. Stakeholders considered relevant: focus on the client perspective; perspective on QoL broader than health; the possibility to take diversity into account; and the possibility to determine a minimum level of QoL. Three facilitators for implementation of the tool were mentioned as well as four barriers. The EQLT can support conversations with clients about their needs and wishes, thus enabling decisions about care services based on a broad set of domains of QoL. Implementation of the tool should take into account the facilitators and barriers identified in the current study.