Controlling cooling: On million-year time scales, Earth's climate state is determined by sources and sinks of carbon to the ocean-atmosphere system. But which specific mechanisms are important in controlling the timing of glacial intervals? Macdonald et al. identify arc-continent collisions in the tropics as a primary control (see the Perspective by Hartmann). They compiled a database of Phanerozoic arc-continent collisions and the latitudinal distribution of ice sheets, showing that ice coverage was greatest when those collisions were most widespread, maximizing global weatherability. Science , this issue p. 181 ; see also p. 126
24 September 2020 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Significance: The Southeast Asian islands are a modern-day hotspot of CO 2 consumption via silicate weathering. Since ∼15 million years ago, these islands have been increasing in size at the same time that Earth’s climate has been cooling. Here, we test the hypothesis that this global cooling could have been driven by tectonic emergence of the Southeast Asian islands. Using a compilation of paleoshorelines, in conjunction with a coupled silicate weathering and climate model, we find that this emergence is associated with a large decrease in p CO 2 . Without these changes in tropical island paleogeography, there would not have been large Northern Hemisphere ice sheets as a defining feature of Earth’s climate over the past 3 million years.
In order to understand the onset of Snowball Earth events, precise geochronology and chemostratigraphy are needed on complete sections leading into the glaciations. While deposits associated with the Neoproterozoic Sturtian glaciation have been found on nearly every continent, time-calibrated stratigraphic sections that record paleoenvironmental conditions leading into the glaciation are exceedingly rare. Instead, the transition to glaciation is normally expressed as erosive contacts with overlying diamictites, and the best existing geochronological constraints come from volcanic successions with little paleoenvironmental information. We report new stratigraphic and geochronological data from the upper Tambien Group in northern Ethiopia, which indicates that the glacigenic diamictite at the top of the succession is Sturtian in age. U-Pb zircon dates obtained from two tuffaceous siltstones that are 74 and 84 m below the diamictite are 719.68 ± 0.46 Ma and 719.68 ± 0.56 Ma (2σ), respectively. We also report a U-Pb date of 735.25 ± 0.25 Ma from a crystal-rich tuff located 2 m above the nadir of a high-amplitude, basin-wide, negative δ13C excursion previously correlated with the Islay anomaly. This age for the anomaly agrees with Re-Os age constraints from Laurentia, suggesting that the δ13C signal is globally synchronous and preceded the Sturtian glaciation by ~18 m.y. The interval between the Islay anomaly and Sturtian glaciation is recorded in the Tambien Group as an ~600 m succession of predominantly shallow-water carbonates and siliciclastics with δ13C values recording a prolonged period at +5‰, followed by an interval of lower, but still positive, values leading up to the glaciation. Our data are consistent with synchronous global onset of the Sturtian glaciation at ca. 717 Ma. Shallow-water carbonates in strata directly below the first diamictite suggest that glacial onset was rapid in terranes of the Arabian-Nubian Shield.
9 June 2021 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
The Tonian supercontinent Rodinia is hypothesized to have included almost all Proterozoic continental blocks. Competing models variably place South China at the core or periphery of Rodinia or separated from it entirely. Tonian paleogeographic models also vary in whether they incorporate hypothesized large and rapid oscillatory true polar wander associated with the ca. 810–795 Ma Bitter Springs Stage. Here, we present paleomagnetic data paired with U‐Pb chemical abrasion isotope dilution thermal ionization mass spectrometry zircon geochronology from the Tonian Xiajiang Group in South China to establish the craton's position and test the Bitter Springs Stage true polar wander hypothesis. Fine‐grained siliciclastic sediments and ashes of the Xiajiang Group post‐date the Jiangnan Orogeny, which united the Yangtze and Cathaysia blocks. A U‐Pb zircon date of 815.73 ± 0.18 Ma from a tuff near the base of the Xiajiang Group constrains the Jiangnan Orogeny to have ended between ca. 830 and 816 Ma. The paleomagnetic and geochronologic data constrain South China to high latitudes ca. 813 Ma and indicate a relatively stable high‐latitude position from ca. 821 to 805 Ma. These high‐latitude constraints either connect the craton to Rodinia along its periphery or disconnect it from the supercontinent entirely. The difference in pole position between the pre‐Bitter Springs Stage Xiajiang Group pole and the syn‐Bitter Springs Stage Madiyi Formation pole is significantly less than that predicted for the Bitter Springs Stage true polar wander hypothesis. If this pole difference is interpreted as true polar wander superimposed upon differential plate motion, it requires South China to have been separate from Rodinia.
One of the hypothesized effects of large igneous provinces (LIPs) is planetary cooling on million‐year timescales associated with enhanced silicate weathering of freshly emplaced basalt. This study combines reconstructions of the original surface extent and emplacement ages of LIPs, a paleogeographic model, and a parameterization of LIP erosion to estimate LIP area in all latitudinal bands through the Phanerozoic. This analysis reveals no significant correlation between total LIP area, nor LIP area in the tropics, and the extent of continental ice sheets. The largest peaks in tropical LIP area are at times of non‐glacial climate. These results suggest that changes in planetary weatherability associated with LIPs are not the fundamental control on whether Earth is in a glacial or non‐glacial climate, although they could provide a secondary modulating effect in conjunction with other processes.
19 July 2021 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences