The principle of respect for the national identities of the Member States is directed principally at the Member States and defines the relationship between the Member States and the European Union. The conceptual scope of the principle itself includes two levels: ethical and institutional. The first covers such elements as history, culture, tradition, language and religion. The other is connected with the constitutional identity of a Member State. The principle of respect for national identity is first of all used in the context of restrictions on the effectiveness of EU law in the legal systems of the Member States. These States can invoke one of the elements shaping the national identity in order to, for example, limit the freedoms of the Internal Market. It should be emphasized that the limiting conditions include not only the ethical space, but also the institutional one, e.g. the protection of human rights or a threat to public order. Secondly, respect for national identity in the institutional space, as constitutional identity, is a basic argument in the discussion on the exclusive competences of Member States and the preservation of sovereignty by the Member States. In the context of the rights of migrant citizens of the European Union, it seems that the impact of the discussed principle is limited. The catalog of citizen rights does not refer directly to this principle. As has been shown above, the solution is to invoke the prohibition of discrimination based on origin, which can effectively protect the national language, religion or other elements shaping the national identity of the country of origin. However, this view is not entirely right. In the Avello case the Court of Justice referred to a problem that exceeded the competence of the European Union and ruled on matters falling within the exclusive competence of the Member States. The Court decided that attribution of family name to children with dual citizenship in accordance with the tradition and culture of the migrant's country of origin has higher value than division of competences. The principle of respect for the national identity of the Member States indirectly affects the obligations of a migrant citizen to the host country. It is not possible to accept the thesis that it is a civic duty, but in certain areas it shapes indirectly the obligations of a migrant citizen to a Member State. The citizen is obligated to respect the order, security and public health of the host country. The consequence of violation of this obligation is expulsion from the host state's territory or refusal to grant the right of residence.
The present article is an attempt to answer the question about the position of the principle of respect for constitutional identities of Member States and its impact on the application of EU law in the national legal order. For this purpose three areas will be considered. Firstly, the analysis of the principle of respect for national identity in EU law and in the case law of the Court of Justice will be conducted. Secondly, the principle of competence entrusted to the EU will be analysed, together with its interpretation at the EU level. Thirdly, the understanding of the notion of constitutional identity in the case law of Constitutional Courts of selected Member States will be considered. It proved that the principle of respect for constitutional identity is treated both at national and EU level as an integral part of the concept of “national identity”. The national identity has a broad meaning and refers to values that are cherished by a particular nation, which it considers to be an element distinguishing that nation from other nations. The constitutional identity narrows the scope and concentrates on the constitutional achievements, the expression of the legal culture and the achievements of the political thought of the nation, which were shaped by the history of a given nation. These two aspects jointly determine the position of the state and nation in international relations. The principle of respect for national identity is one of the constitutional principles of the EU. On one hand, it implies the EU’s duty to undertake activities which do not affect national identity, including constitutional identity, of Member States. On the other hand, it obligates it to ensure the diversity of Member States.
Europejski charakter sądu krajowego Słowa kluczowe: zasada efektywności, zasada efektywnej ochrony prawnej, zasada pierwszeństwa, zasada bezpośredniego skutku i bezpośredniego stosowania, wykładnia prounijna, autonomia proceduralna, pytanie prejudycjalne Keywords: principle of effectiveness, principle of effective legal protection, principle of primacy, principle of direct effect and direct applicability, pro-eu interpretation, procedural autonomy, preliminary ruling
11 December 2020 in Review of European and Comparative Law
The process of European integration has introduced the Member States into a new legal reality. The existing exclusivity in the area of competence implementation has been replaced by a two-stage model of their exercise. The Member States, when conferring part of their supervisory powers, did not specify the scope of their own competences. The so-called European clauses were analysed in the Constitutions of selected Member States, which showed that they define the recipient of the conferral and, in a non-uniform manner, specify the subject of the conferral. The analysis of the indicated provisions clearly shows that the Constitutions of the Member States exclude full conferral of competences on the European Union. There is no specification of the scope of competences that may be conferred. However, this issue was addressed by Constitutional Courts of the Member States. The article refers to the judgements of the German Federal Constitutional Court and the Polish Constitutional Court. It has been shown that they equate exclusive competences of the Member States with the scope of the concept of constitutional identity reduced to basic principles of the state. The Court of Justice of the European Union analysed the scope of competences of both entities. The article presents the analysis of judgements on: entries in Civil Registry regarding transcription of surnames, the issue of recognition of same-sex marriages, reform of the judiciary system in Poland, and the application of the Charter of Fundamental Rights in the areas that do not fall under EU competence. Regardless of the division of competences, the EU is bound by the principle of respect for national identity of the Member States, including constitutional identity. It both obligates the EU to respect the exclusive competences of the Member States and is a premise restricting the achievement of EU objectives.
31 July 2025 in Teka Komisji Prawniczej PAN Oddział w Lublinie
The objective of this article is to analyse the legal situation of Ukrainian nationals following 24 February 2022 from the perspective of migration processes. The analysis focuses on legal measures adopted at the level of the European Union, by Member States neighbouring Ukraine – exemplified by Poland – and by Ukraine itself. Ukrainians were given temporary protection, based on the provisions of Council Directive 2001/55/EC and Council Implementing Decisions (EU) 2022/382, both the acts having led to the adoption of uniform standards of their protection, which are to be observed across EU Member States. At the same time, each Member State has enacted separate legal instruments specifying the manner in which the refugees’ rights granted under EU law are to be exercised within its territory, thereby establishing the legal framework for a safe stay, along with the possibility of full participation in the host country’s economic and social life. With regard to the measures adopted by the Ukrainian authorities, it should be noted that they focus on reconciling the right to freedom of movement with the need to maintain the state’s defensive potential. Particularly, this is sensitive area, as it concerns, on the one hand, the exercise of one of the constitutional freedoms of Ukrainian citizens and, on the other hand, the necessity of ensuring state security, including its defence capabilities. The measures discussed indicate a graduał tightening of legal provisions aimed at preserving military capacity and preventing abuses intended to evade mandatory service in defence of the country. Furthermore, the legal situation of internally displaced persons, who have been granted social assistance by the Ukrainian authorities, is also addressed. The considerations taken in this article support the thesis that only coherent measures – at the level of the European Union, its Member States, and the Ukrainian authorities – can serve to stabilise the situation of Ukrainian nationals in the context of the ongoing Russian aggression.